I always thought market making was a good thing because it provides liquidity to others. That is, until I finished reading the UK FCA’s final rules and realized: if an exchange makes markets on its own platform, it’s both the referee and a player on the field—and it can see everyone’s cards.

On November 18, the UK Treasury added rule 9UA to the regulated activities rules, exempting “making markets on a qualifying crypto platform” from the permission requirement for dealing on own account—but only for third-party market makers. Platform operators are explicitly prohibited from making markets on their own platforms, with the rule taking effect on October 25, 2027. The reasoning is straightforward: the platform can see order flow, your limit orders, and your stop-losses. That advantage doesn’t come from winning through technology; it comes from having the upper hand.

What really struck me was something else: who provides a platform’s market depth and tight spreads? If it’s the platform itself or an affiliate making markets, you think you’re trading against the market, but your counterparty is actually the person running the casino. These rules don’t impose a blanket ban on market making and drive liquidity away. Instead, they draw a line: “third parties can do it; the platform itself can’t.” That amounts to acknowledging one thing—market depth is valuable, but it shouldn’t be the house putting on a show for you.

On-chain, everyone talks about transparency. Yet off-chain regulators are the ones stepping in first to tackle this structural advantage: being able to see everyone else’s cards. When choosing a platform from now on, don’t just focus on depth and fees. First ask: who’s actually providing that depth?

#加密监管 #FCA #Web3 #加密市场 $BTC $ETH