After reading CoinDesk’s report on Bitcoin’s quantum risk, the thing that went against my intuition wasn’t quantum computing—it was “people.” The real killer isn’t how fast a quantum computer can calculate someday, but how to move the more than 6 million BTC whose public keys have already been exposed on-chain. According to Glassnode, that’s over 30% of the circulating supply, including many early addresses that haven’t moved in more than a decade. Estimates suggest Satoshi’s coins are among them. There’s a line from Cysic CEO Leo Fan that stuck with me: the clock that really matters is migration, not machines. Technically, post-quantum signature standards are more or less settled, but there’s no one who can order the entire Bitcoin network to upgrade its wallets. Nodes, miners, developers, and custodians first have to argue their way to a consensus, then go one by one and ask every holder to move their coins themselves. Even harder are the multisig and threshold signatures used by exchanges and custodians. The single-user version has been standardized, but the multi-user version is still in the lab; BitGo’s test in May was only a simulation.
So developers are now stuck arguing over the same question: should coins that will never move be frozen or left alone? Lopp says it’s better to freeze them in advance than have them stolen by quantum thieves later. Adam Back says that would punish honest holders. Neither side has convinced the other, and BIP 360 and 361 are still drafts.
The more I think about it, the more I feel this isn’t a cryptography problem but a sociology problem: code can be upgraded, but people’s minds can’t. The number of 6 million coins won’t shrink by itself; whoever doesn’t move their coins will remain exposed. Don’t just fixate on when a quantum computer will be built—first check which address your own coins are sitting in.
#比特币 #量子安全 #Web3 #CryptoSecurity
$BTC $ETH $SOL
So developers are now stuck arguing over the same question: should coins that will never move be frozen or left alone? Lopp says it’s better to freeze them in advance than have them stolen by quantum thieves later. Adam Back says that would punish honest holders. Neither side has convinced the other, and BIP 360 and 361 are still drafts.
The more I think about it, the more I feel this isn’t a cryptography problem but a sociology problem: code can be upgraded, but people’s minds can’t. The number of 6 million coins won’t shrink by itself; whoever doesn’t move their coins will remain exposed. Don’t just fixate on when a quantum computer will be built—first check which address your own coins are sitting in.
#比特币 #量子安全 #Web3 #CryptoSecurity
$BTC $ETH $SOL