I always thought the biggest risk of holding crypto treasury stocks like these was a drop in coin prices. It wasn’t until I read about MSCI’s decision over the past couple of days that I realized the real killer is being removed from an index.

MSCI plans to kick Strategy and Metaplanet out of its indexes at the close on November 30, with the change taking effect on December 1. JPMorgan estimates this will force passive funds to sell around $2.8 billion worth of MSTR shares. If other index providers follow suit, the total could reach $8.8 billion. Strategy has calculated that index funds hold about 13 million shares, or 3.1% of its basic shares outstanding.

Some people ask: what does selling shares have to do with Bitcoin? A lot. The lifeblood of this treasury business model is issuing shares at a premium and using the proceeds to buy coins: when the share price is above net asset value, the company can issue shares at a high price and buy coins at a lower price, making the flywheel spin faster and faster. Now MSTR’s mNAV has fallen to 0.98x, below net asset value. Add in its removal from the index, and passive buying turns into passive selling—the flywheel reverses outright. It doesn’t have to sell a single coin; the share price alone can shut off its financing channel.

The irony is that two years ago, MicroStrategy’s inclusion in the MSCI index was celebrated as a major win for the crypto world: retirement accounts could finally gain indirect, compliant exposure to Bitcoin. Now that same door has ushered it out. When assessing companies like this, stop looking at how many more coins they’ve bought. First ask whether anyone is still willing to pay a premium for their stock.

#比特币 #财库股 #Web3 $BTC $MSTR $ETH