ChainCatcher reports that Brian Quintenz, a board member of prediction market platform Kalshi and a former commissioner of the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission, said insider trading is far more common in the stock market than in prediction markets, but links between traders and event outcomes are easier to identify in prediction markets. Speaking Thursday at the Capitol Crypto Forum, hosted by The Hill and The Block, he said insider trading occurs far more often in the stock market than in derivatives and prediction markets, and is easier to spot because the connections are very direct.
Quintenz believes that the possibility of insider trading should not make a market illegal or invalid, and that enforcement against violations should complement exchanges’ preventive efforts. Former CFTC commissioner and Millennium Management vice chairman of regulatory affairs Dan Berkovitz said that, in addition to anti-insider-trading rules, exchanges need to set participation limits and strict anti-manipulation provisions, including restricting employees of organizations related to a contract and people who can influence its outcome from participating. Citing markets based on whether someone says a particular word as an example, he noted that whoever can decide whether the word is spoken can also determine the contract’s outcome.
Former CFTC Commissioner Christy Goldsmith Romero said exchanges are the first line of defense against insider trading, that the CFTC needs to do more, and that it should provide clearer guidance on certification standards for determining whether contracts are not readily susceptible to manipulation. Quintenz agreed that more guidance is needed, but said the CFTC should explain how the standards apply rather than leaving each exchange to set its own. On sports event contracts, Goldsmith Romero said that, given the conflicting rulings among the circuit courts, the Supreme Court may take up the issue, and she believes prediction markets could lose the case involving sports contracts.
