For years the standard advice in crypto has been simple: get your coins off exchanges and onto a hardware wallet. This week a reminder landed that a hardware wallet reduces risk, but does not remove it.
According to a Binance News report citing Odaily, Coinkite CEO Rodolfo Novak said about 0.17% of Coldcard users were affected by a firmware vulnerability. Coldcard is one of the best-known Bitcoin-only hardware wallets, popular with exactly the kind of careful, long-term holders who do everything "right." The headline number attached to the incident is more than $100 million in stolen bitcoin.
Here is what is actually known, what is not, and what any hardware wallet owner can do today.
**1. What we know**
- **The vendor's figure:** Novak put the affected share at roughly 0.17% of Coldcard users. He did not say how many people that is.
- **The outside estimate:** In September, Galaxy Head of Research Alex Thorn said about 9,200 addresses had been compromised, involving 1,830 BTC, worth about $116 million at the time.
- **Victims who came forward:** Thorn also said 256 Coldcard victims contacted Galaxy for help. Of those, 245 held 2,585 addresses containing a total of 895 BTC.
- **Timeline:** The first reported Coldcard theft was on 30 July. Coinkite says it is preparing a technical postmortem.
- **Legal:** A proposed class-action lawsuit was filed in Ontario in September naming Coinkite, Novak and co-founder Peter Gray. It seeks to represent people who bought specified Coldcard models directly from Coinkite for personal use.
**2. What we don't know**
This is the uncomfortable part. Coinkite has not released sales figures, so "0.17% of users" cannot be turned into a headcount. The company has also said its privacy-focused design means it cannot verify outside estimates of losses. And until the postmortem is published, the exact technical cause, which models and firmware versions were involved, and how the attack worked are not public in detail.
That gap matters. When the facts are thin, rumours, fake "fix" tools and fake support accounts fill the space. That is often when the second wave of losses happens.
Novak's own public conduct has added noise. He recently said he would leave the industry and step back, without saying whether he would resign as CEO, and he called some critics bots belonging to competitors. None of that changes what users need to do.
**3. The bigger lesson: "cold" is a spectrum**
A hardware wallet protects you from the most common attacks: malware on your laptop, phishing pages, exchange failures. It does that by keeping the signing key on a separate device. But you are still trusting:
- the firmware on that device,
- the way your seed was generated,
- the supply chain that delivered the device to you,
- and your own backup.
Most of the time that trust is well placed. This incident shows it is still trust. For large holdings, the question is not "hardware wallet or not," it is "how many independent things have to fail before I lose everything?"
**4. Practical checklist for any hardware wallet owner**
This is general hygiene, not a fix for the Coldcard issue specifically. Wait for Coinkite's official postmortem for model-specific guidance.
- **Get firmware news only from the official site.** Type the address yourself. Ignore DMs, emails and "support" replies offering firmware files or recovery tools. No real support agent will ever ask for your seed phrase.
- **Never type your seed phrase into anything** except the hardware device itself during a genuine recovery. Not a website, not an app, not a "wallet checker."
- **Consider whether your setup has a single point of failure.** If one device, one seed and one vendor are all that stand between you and your savings, multisig across different hardware vendors is worth reading about. A 2-of-3 setup means one compromised device is not enough to move funds.
- **Use a passphrase if you understand it.** An extra word on top of the seed adds a second factor, but losing it means losing access, so back it up carefully.
- **Watch your addresses.** A watch-only wallet or block explorer bookmark lets you notice unexpected movement fast.
- **Split by purpose.** Coins you trade belong in one place, long-term savings in another, with stronger protection on the second.
- **If you believe you were affected,** document everything, follow only official Coinkite channels, and be very sceptical of "recovery services" that ask for upfront payment.
**5. Why this matters beyond one brand**
Self-custody is still the right goal for many people. The Coldcard episode doesn't argue against it. It argues against treating any single product as a guarantee. The safest holders assume any one layer can fail, and build so that one failure isn't the end.
When Coinkite publishes the postmortem, read the primary source rather than summaries. Until then: no panic moves, no clicking links, no seed phrases anywhere.
How do you store your long-term coins: single hardware wallet, multisig, or something else? Tell me in the comments.
Not financial advice. Do your own research.
#Bitcoin #CryptoSecurity #SelfCustody