Seeing this ruling, my first reaction was: the gray area on Ethereum where people make a living from transaction ordering has been marked off by the court with one line: “There was no promise.”

On November 16, Judge Jessica Clarke of the Southern District of New York acquitted brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud, and conspiracy to commit money laundering, bringing the case to a close. Prosecutors had accused them of using eight bait transactions in 2023 to lure sandwich bots, then exploiting a vulnerability in relay software to rearrange transaction ordering, causing the bots to lose about $25 million. It was the first criminal case in the United States targeting MEV operations.

The judge’s reasoning is worth reading for everyone who trades on $ETH : the bait transactions did not constitute a promise, the relay had not verified the forged field, and that field had no effect on the recipient’s behavior. She even wrote that Ethereum is “a trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of service.”

What does this mean for ordinary users of $ETH ? If you’re the one being sandwiched, the path of criminal prosecution is essentially closed off; the court isn’t going to treat losses in an adversarial environment as fraud and make you whole. I can understand why some people feel aggrieved, but the ruling is there: under the current rules, the fight over ordering rights is closer to a jungle than to something within the reach of fraud law.