Last night, CZ posted a long thread explaining why the market fell this time. He started by saying that nobody can know for sure, and that correlation doesn’t equal causation. Then he listed several factors: money shifting to Anthropic’s IPO; U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs seeing roughly $1.9 billion in outflows over seven consecutive trading days through November 13; security incidents (the Binance hack, Apple Wallet, Chrome, and the Microsoft outage); hotter-than-expected U.S. inflation raising rate-hike expectations; interest rates and the dollar; and policy uncertainty after the midterm elections. He denied that Binance was selling and said he’d bought crypto over the past few days. He wrote that Bitcoin had hit a low of 62006 that day, leaving it there for comparison later.
The post has now passed 1.7 million views, and people in the comments are sharing it too. I’ll spell out which points are grounded in facts and which are just stories.
I’m still not buying the Anthropic argument. Pricing is this Wednesday, and it’s set to list on Nasdaq on Thursday under the ticker ANT. U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs don’t trade over the weekend. But from Saturday to Sunday this week, Binance spot Bitcoin still plunged from around 64,000 to 62006. Blaming that weekend leg on an IPO that hasn’t even been priced yet doesn’t fit the timeline. The SpaceX overlay chart he shared is even less convincing: it lines up two drops, then concludes that the market could bottom around the IPO and, following the same pattern as last time, reach 90,000 around February next year. That’s a comparison of price movements, not an explanation of who’s selling or where the money is going. Two declines looking alike doesn’t prove that the same people are freeing up cash for subscriptions this time around.
The ETF outflow point is real. Through the 13th, roughly $1.9 billion flowed out over seven consecutive trading days, matching the figures we’d checked earlier and helping explain the selling pressure on weekdays. But it still doesn’t explain why prices kept falling over the weekend.
Security incidents can serve as background, but making them the main reason for this weekend’s plunge is a stretch. The Binance hack happened at the end of October, and the Microsoft outage had nothing to do with people selling Bitcoin.
The inflation and rate-hike point is real too. Today, Xinhua Finance and Securities Times relayed CME FedWatch figures: the probability of a 25-basis-point rate hike in December is 95%, and the probability of a 50-basis-point hike is 5%. The question is no longer whether rates will rise, but by how much. It’s reasonable to say this could prompt a repricing of risk assets.
One thing CZ didn’t mention, but which I think matters more, is another set of figures. On the 14th, Glassnode reported that the total supply of stablecoins had fallen by roughly $17 billion over the past month—the steepest drop since 2022. On the 11th, it had initially reported a $14.2 billion decline over 30 days; two days later, that figure was revised upward to $17 billion. This isn’t just people switching positions within the market; some are converting stablecoins back into fiat, leaving less available cash to buy crypto.
At noon today, Binance spot Bitcoin was around 65006. It had reached a 24-hour high of 66132 before slipping back, leaving it nearly flat. Ethereum was around 1825. The bounce from 62006 yesterday had already failed to hold near 66,000 during the day. The Fear & Greed Index is still at 10, in extreme fear territory.
I’d put the main causes of this decline where the numbers point: ETFs are seeing outflows, stablecoins are being redeemed, and rate-hike expectations are rising. The Anthropic story sounds good and even comes with a timeline for a rebound after the listing, but it doesn’t explain the weekend move or why the amount of dollars in the market itself is shrinking. There’s Nvidia’s earnings report, Anthropic’s pricing, and its listing this week, so the market could swing around. But this move from 62,000 to 65,000 looks less like new money coming in and more like a bounce after liquidations, with buying support underneath still thinning out. If 62,000 gets knocked through again this week, it won’t be because liquidity suddenly disappeared on Thursday.
#比特币 #Stablecoins
The post has now passed 1.7 million views, and people in the comments are sharing it too. I’ll spell out which points are grounded in facts and which are just stories.
I’m still not buying the Anthropic argument. Pricing is this Wednesday, and it’s set to list on Nasdaq on Thursday under the ticker ANT. U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs don’t trade over the weekend. But from Saturday to Sunday this week, Binance spot Bitcoin still plunged from around 64,000 to 62006. Blaming that weekend leg on an IPO that hasn’t even been priced yet doesn’t fit the timeline. The SpaceX overlay chart he shared is even less convincing: it lines up two drops, then concludes that the market could bottom around the IPO and, following the same pattern as last time, reach 90,000 around February next year. That’s a comparison of price movements, not an explanation of who’s selling or where the money is going. Two declines looking alike doesn’t prove that the same people are freeing up cash for subscriptions this time around.
The ETF outflow point is real. Through the 13th, roughly $1.9 billion flowed out over seven consecutive trading days, matching the figures we’d checked earlier and helping explain the selling pressure on weekdays. But it still doesn’t explain why prices kept falling over the weekend.
Security incidents can serve as background, but making them the main reason for this weekend’s plunge is a stretch. The Binance hack happened at the end of October, and the Microsoft outage had nothing to do with people selling Bitcoin.
The inflation and rate-hike point is real too. Today, Xinhua Finance and Securities Times relayed CME FedWatch figures: the probability of a 25-basis-point rate hike in December is 95%, and the probability of a 50-basis-point hike is 5%. The question is no longer whether rates will rise, but by how much. It’s reasonable to say this could prompt a repricing of risk assets.
One thing CZ didn’t mention, but which I think matters more, is another set of figures. On the 14th, Glassnode reported that the total supply of stablecoins had fallen by roughly $17 billion over the past month—the steepest drop since 2022. On the 11th, it had initially reported a $14.2 billion decline over 30 days; two days later, that figure was revised upward to $17 billion. This isn’t just people switching positions within the market; some are converting stablecoins back into fiat, leaving less available cash to buy crypto.
At noon today, Binance spot Bitcoin was around 65006. It had reached a 24-hour high of 66132 before slipping back, leaving it nearly flat. Ethereum was around 1825. The bounce from 62006 yesterday had already failed to hold near 66,000 during the day. The Fear & Greed Index is still at 10, in extreme fear territory.
I’d put the main causes of this decline where the numbers point: ETFs are seeing outflows, stablecoins are being redeemed, and rate-hike expectations are rising. The Anthropic story sounds good and even comes with a timeline for a rebound after the listing, but it doesn’t explain the weekend move or why the amount of dollars in the market itself is shrinking. There’s Nvidia’s earnings report, Anthropic’s pricing, and its listing this week, so the market could swing around. But this move from 62,000 to 65,000 looks less like new money coming in and more like a bounce after liquidations, with buying support underneath still thinning out. If 62,000 gets knocked through again this week, it won’t be because liquidity suddenly disappeared on Thursday.
#比特币 #Stablecoins
