There’s a historical pattern in the U.S. stock market: “The S&P 500 has risen 19 times in a row after U.S. midterm elections!” Could it follow the same pattern and rise again this time?

Let me break down why people have reached this conclusion.

Looking back at the 19 U.S. midterm elections from 1950 to 2022, the S&P 500 posted a positive return in the 12 months following every election, with an average gain of about 15.1%.

Why does the U.S. stock market often perform better after midterm elections?

I think there are three main reasons:

Reduced uncertainty: Before an election, markets worry about changes in policy, taxes, regulation, and fiscal priorities. Once the results are in, investors can reassess the policy environment for the next two years.

A period of political bargaining: If the presidency and Congress are controlled by different parties, major policy initiatives may face more checks and balances. The pace and scale of policy changes both affect market expectations.

The presidential term cycle: Historical data shows that the third year of a president’s term—the year before a reelection campaign—is often one of the strongest years for stocks in a four-year term. But this is only a historical pattern; it doesn’t mean the government will necessarily boost the stock market with stimulus policies.

In many past midterm election years, markets came under pressure before the election. This time, too, the market started falling before the election. The AI boom had been driving tech stocks higher, but now AI-related trading has dragged the whole market down. It’s hard not to wonder whether AI is actually in a bubble.

Keep an eye on three key variables:

The Federal Reserve: The interest-rate path and the 10-year Treasury yield determine whether market valuations can continue to expand.

Tech earnings: Will AI investments by companies like NVDA, MSFT, GOOG, and AMZN ultimately translate into revenue and profits?

Market sentiment: Are investors still willing to take on risk and keep buying?

Oil prices have fallen too. Could we see a situation where falling oil prices lift the prices of everything else? Gold is the first thing to show it, and
$BTC
The U.S. stock market, on the other hand, hasn’t moved at all.

Especially this year, AI valuations, capital spending by tech giants, and interest-rate expectations could all prove to be turning points for the market. If earnings continue to come through and the rate environment is supportive, the market could rebound. But if AI investments take a long time to pay off, or Treasury yields rise again, the market could keep correcting.

Tech stocks have already fallen quite a bit. I’m waiting too, hoping for a decent rebound—and for some certainty.