M-O-N-A-R-C-H
NFA | Options Only While Hedging | Quality Matters Whether Little but Quality Matters | First Learn Then Earn | Don’t Depend On Any1, Become Self Sufficient. |
68 Following
675 Followers
1.1K+ Liked
Posts
All
Quotes
Videos
Live
PINNED
PINNED
M-O-N-A-R-C-H
·
--
Live + Verified Feature Only Be Accessible to Those who pass the Test.
Verified ≠ Profitable: Binance’s Traders, Verified Creators and the Reality Behind the Badge
Data as of November 12, 2026 · Educational research, not financial advice · Binance figures are company-reported and unaudited
The short version
Binance reports 323 million+ registered users, but its own 2025 survey found about half see themselves as long-term holders, not active traders. “Trader” is a far smaller group than the headline number.“Verified” on Binance can mean an identity check, a follower threshold, a performance snapshot or a lead-trader approval. None of them is an audited track record.Creators and lead traders are mostly paid on activity (followers’ trading fees, volume, ROI rankings), not on whether followers end up ahead.Studies from Brazil, Europe and the BIS keep finding that most retail leveraged traders lose money, and no public Binance dataset on how followers of verified traders actually perform could be found.In November 2026 on-chain analysts alleged that some crypto influencers sell from hidden “side wallets” into their own followers. The cases found are on Solana, not Binance, but the same mechanics exist wherever a visible trader has a following.Backdrop: Binance’s October 29 hack (reportedly about USD 6 billion, attributed by TRM Labs to a North Korea–linked group; Binance says user funds are safe) has put trust across the whole ecosystem under a microscope.
1. How many traders are there, really?
Users: 323 million+ registered users across 100+ countries as of July 14, 2026, which Binance says is roughly 43% of the ~741 million people who own crypto.Volume: about USD 34 trillion traded across products in 2025, plus roughly USD 11.4 trillion in the first half of 2026.Traders vs holders: in Binance’s 2025 User Pulse survey (95,000+ users in 48 markets), about half of users called themselves long-term holders rather than active traders.Binance Square: Binance described it as reaching 35 million+ monthly active users when it launched Trader Profile in early 2025.What isn’t public: no official count of active traders, verified creators or lead traders could be found. In 2024 a Binance spokesperson did not disclose what share of users had tried copy trading.
2. Five things “verified” can mean on Binance
KYC-verified account. Required to trade and to post on Square. It proves Binance knows who you are, and nothing about skill or honesty.Gold checkmark (Square). Identity verification, a completed profile and 30,000 followers on Square or major social channels. The “Verified+” tier adds 300,000 quarterly views or USD 1 million in Write to Earn volume, and status is reviewed every quarter. It proves identity, reach and activity, not performance. A black checkmark marks official Binance accounts, and separate “Top Voice” badges require regular article output (four articles in 30 days to qualify).Trader Profile and Trading Badges. An opt-in portfolio breakdown, P&L and badges tied to account performance. P&L is shown as a percentage only, with no absolute values, so +200% on USD 100 looks identical to +200% on USD 100,000.Smart Money (successor to the Futures Leaderboard). Shows the top 100 users who agreed to share their positions, and its stats exclude trading bots and copy trading. That is a self-selected top slice, a textbook setup for survivorship bias.Lead trader (copy trading). A verified account with a portfolio inside the allowed range (500 to 1,000,000 USDT on spot). It proves the trader meets Binance’s thresholds, not that followers profit.
In May 2025 Binance also added Trade Sharing Cards, which attach real spot and futures trades to posts in place of screenshots. That is a genuine step toward transparency, but it shows individual trades, not a full track record.
3. How verified traders get paid
Write to Earn: open to all KYC-verified users since early 2026. The base commission is 20% of the trading fees your readers generate, rising to as much as 50% for top-ranked weekly creators. In 2024 the ceiling was 30%.Copy trading: lead traders take a profit share (10% on spot; on futures it starts at 10% and can reach up to 30% on higher tiers) plus 10% of their followers’ trading fees.Affiliate links: in 2023 Fortune reported a network of about 26,000 Binance influencer-affiliates, with commissions of up to 40% of referred users’ fees and some earning over USD 1 million a year.Contests: Traders League campaigns have run multi-million-dollar prize pools (Season 4: about USD 4 million), including ROI-ranked futures competitions and a USD 50,000 Live Showdown for streaming creators.
The pattern: nearly every channel pays when followers trade, not when followers profit. A profit share only pays on gains, but fee commissions and rebates pay on every trade, win or lose. That is a design fact, not an accusation, yet it explains how a creator can look generous while being financially aligned with your activity rather than your results.
One more gap: when Binance launched its Live Trading Hub in May 2025 (verified creators with 1,000+ followers can stream while viewers place spot or futures trades inside the stream), it had not disclosed guardrails on creator liability or required disclaimers.
4. The reality of trading: what the numbers say
Brazil: among day traders who persisted more than 300 days, 97% lost money, and only about 1.1% earned more than minimum wage.Europe (CFDs): regulators found 74% to 89% of retail accounts lost money; UK broker disclosures show roughly 60% to 80%.Germany: BaFin found 74.2% of retail turbo-certificate traders lost money from 2019 to 2023, averaging €6,358 per loser and more than €3.4 billion in total.Bitcoin: BIS research reported in 2022 estimated that 73% to 81% of retail users likely lost money on their crypto investments.Influencer calls: a CoinWire study of X posts found 76% of promoted tokens later lost 90% or more of their value, and accounts above 200,000 followers promoted the worst performers (an average of −89% after three months). Binance’s gold badge starts at 30,000 followers.
How to read Binance’s own metrics:
ROI ignores account size and time.Win rate ignores payoff size; a 70% win rate can still lose money if the losses are bigger.Max drawdown is only as meaningful as the period it covers.Leverage matters more than most stats. Binance’s futures copy-trading launch included risk tags: yellow for 10x to 20x and red above 20x.Follower results differ from the leader’s because of fees, slippage and each follower’s own settings.
Independent and exchange-published analyses describe a wide gap between lead traders’ results and their followers’ results. There is no audited Binance dataset to confirm or refute that for Binance specifically, and that absence is itself a finding.
5. The controversy, sorted by strength of evidence
Documented in court filings
On March 31, 2023, a USD 1 billion lawsuit was filed in a Florida federal court against Binance, its then-CEO and three high-profile promoters (an NBA player and two YouTubers), alleging promotion of unregistered securities. These are plaintiffs’ allegations, not findings. Check the case’s current status before citing it.
Published investigations (allegations, not court findings)
Between November 5 and 9, 2026, on-chain analytics firm Bubblemaps alleged that some crypto traders attract followers with a visible wallet while selling from linked “side wallets.” In one case it alleged about USD 1.74 million was extracted through roughly 30 linked wallets since May 7, by selling into copy traders. In another it alleged side wallets bought before about 61% of a trader’s callouts and sold within minutes. Bubblemaps also criticized leaderboards, affiliate links and callout rewards for encouraging the behavior, and called for audits of top traders, disclosure of linked wallets and bans for repeat offenders. No public response from the trader in the USD 1.74 million case was found in the sources reviewed.Scope matters: these cases involve Solana memecoin traders. In the sources reviewed, none involve Binance Square creators or Binance copy trading. They matter here because the architecture is the same: a visible track record, a following and rewards for activity.
Disputed and unverified
On November 6 and 7, 2026, a celebrity-token promoter whose own history has been questioned by on-chain analysts published leaked chats claiming several well-known influencers took undisclosed payments to promote tokens in 2024. Those named dispute the claims, coverage notes that none of the payments is proven, and on-chain checks of at least one headline transfer have been challenged. Treat it as unproven.
What this means for Binance’s community
Trade Sharing Cards, Trader Profile and Smart Money are real improvements over screenshots.But no published Binance data on aggregate follower outcomes, no audit of top traders’ linked accounts and no disclosure rules for live-stream creators could be found. Those are the gaps the wider critique is pointing at.
6. A checklist before you follow any “verified” trader
Ask for absolute numbers: account size, realized P&L, max drawdown and days active, not ROI alone.Check leverage and liquidation history, not just the winning streak.Look for conflicts: are they earning Write to Earn commissions, referral fees or rebates on the trade they are promoting?Prefer verified trade cards over screenshots, and check whether holdings were disclosed when they posted.Compare a lead trader’s results with what followers actually received.Wait for a full market cycle, including a deep drawdown, before trusting a streak.Size every copy-trade or signal as money you can afford to lose.
Bottom line
“Verified” tells you who someone is. It doesn’t tell you what you would earn by following them. Binance’s newer tools make individual trades easier to check, but the platform still doesn’t publish how followers fare as a group, and most of the money flowing to creators depends on activity rather than outcomes. Until that changes, treat a badge as an ID check, not a track record.
What could not be verified
The number of active traders, verified creators or lead traders on Binance.Aggregate performance of copy-trading followers or leaderboard traders.The current status of the 2023 lawsuit.Whether any of the November 2026 allegations will be confirmed. They remain allegations.
Sources
Binance (official)
Binance Square verification checkmark: requirementsBinance Square FAQ (black vs gold checkmarks)Top Voices badgeSpot copy trading: lead trader requirementsFutures copy trading FAQLead Trader Growth PlanFutures Smart Money FAQTrader Profile (Binance blog, Feb 2025)Share Your Trades on Binance Square (Binance blog, May 2025)Write to Earn: up to 50% commission (Binance Square)Write to Earn: up to 30% (Binance Square, Aug 2024)
Company figures and coverage
Binance marks nine years (press release, July 14, 2026)Datawallet: Binance statistics for 2026Invezz: Binance at nine yearsBinance hits 300 million users (2025 User Pulse survey)MPost: Trader Profile launch and Square’s 35M monthly usersTraders Union: Trading BadgesCrypto Briefing: Live Trading HubThe Block: spot copy trading (April 2024)Benzinga: futures copy trading risk tagsThe Tribune: Traders League Season 4Taiwan News: Futures Traders League and Live ShowdownFortune: Binance’s influencer army (April 2023)Cointelegraph: USD 1 billion lawsuit (2023)CNN: Binance hack (October 30, 2026)
Studies on trader outcomes
Brazil day-trading study (summary on Binance Square)ESMA CFD loss rates (PR Newswire summary)Wolf Street: UK CFD loss ratesFinance Magnates: BaFin turbo-certificate studyThe Register: BIS analysis of crypto retail losses (2022)CoinWire influencer meme-coin study (via Binance Square)
Controversy coverage
TokenPost: Bubblemaps urges launchpads to audit top traderscrypto.news: Bubblemaps alleges hidden-wallet abuseKuCoin News: Bubblemaps and hidden walletsBubblemaps thread on X (November 9, 2026)La Sobremesa: the leaked-chats dispute
#HuangRisksOusterOverReportedAffairWithSubordinate #AnthropicRejectsIPODelayValuationinQuestion #ZcashFallsBelow$1000ForFirstTimeSinceSeptember #MSCIRemovalMayCurbStrategy’sBitcoinBuying #CanNvidiaEarningsEaseMarketConcerns?
Data as of November 12, 2026 · Educational research, not financial advice · Binance figures are company-reported and unaudited
The short version
Binance reports 323 million+ registered users, but its own 2025 survey found about half see themselves as long-term holders, not active traders. “Trader” is a far smaller group than the headline number.“Verified” on Binance can mean an identity check, a follower threshold, a performance snapshot or a lead-trader approval. None of them is an audited track record.Creators and lead traders are mostly paid on activity (followers’ trading fees, volume, ROI rankings), not on whether followers end up ahead.Studies from Brazil, Europe and the BIS keep finding that most retail leveraged traders lose money, and no public Binance dataset on how followers of verified traders actually perform could be found.In November 2026 on-chain analysts alleged that some crypto influencers sell from hidden “side wallets” into their own followers. The cases found are on Solana, not Binance, but the same mechanics exist wherever a visible trader has a following.Backdrop: Binance’s October 29 hack (reportedly about USD 6 billion, attributed by TRM Labs to a North Korea–linked group; Binance says user funds are safe) has put trust across the whole ecosystem under a microscope.
1. How many traders are there, really?
Users: 323 million+ registered users across 100+ countries as of July 14, 2026, which Binance says is roughly 43% of the ~741 million people who own crypto.Volume: about USD 34 trillion traded across products in 2025, plus roughly USD 11.4 trillion in the first half of 2026.Traders vs holders: in Binance’s 2025 User Pulse survey (95,000+ users in 48 markets), about half of users called themselves long-term holders rather than active traders.Binance Square: Binance described it as reaching 35 million+ monthly active users when it launched Trader Profile in early 2025.What isn’t public: no official count of active traders, verified creators or lead traders could be found. In 2024 a Binance spokesperson did not disclose what share of users had tried copy trading.
2. Five things “verified” can mean on Binance
KYC-verified account. Required to trade and to post on Square. It proves Binance knows who you are, and nothing about skill or honesty.Gold checkmark (Square). Identity verification, a completed profile and 30,000 followers on Square or major social channels. The “Verified+” tier adds 300,000 quarterly views or USD 1 million in Write to Earn volume, and status is reviewed every quarter. It proves identity, reach and activity, not performance. A black checkmark marks official Binance accounts, and separate “Top Voice” badges require regular article output (four articles in 30 days to qualify).Trader Profile and Trading Badges. An opt-in portfolio breakdown, P&L and badges tied to account performance. P&L is shown as a percentage only, with no absolute values, so +200% on USD 100 looks identical to +200% on USD 100,000.Smart Money (successor to the Futures Leaderboard). Shows the top 100 users who agreed to share their positions, and its stats exclude trading bots and copy trading. That is a self-selected top slice, a textbook setup for survivorship bias.Lead trader (copy trading). A verified account with a portfolio inside the allowed range (500 to 1,000,000 USDT on spot). It proves the trader meets Binance’s thresholds, not that followers profit.
In May 2025 Binance also added Trade Sharing Cards, which attach real spot and futures trades to posts in place of screenshots. That is a genuine step toward transparency, but it shows individual trades, not a full track record.
3. How verified traders get paid
Write to Earn: open to all KYC-verified users since early 2026. The base commission is 20% of the trading fees your readers generate, rising to as much as 50% for top-ranked weekly creators. In 2024 the ceiling was 30%.Copy trading: lead traders take a profit share (10% on spot; on futures it starts at 10% and can reach up to 30% on higher tiers) plus 10% of their followers’ trading fees.Affiliate links: in 2023 Fortune reported a network of about 26,000 Binance influencer-affiliates, with commissions of up to 40% of referred users’ fees and some earning over USD 1 million a year.Contests: Traders League campaigns have run multi-million-dollar prize pools (Season 4: about USD 4 million), including ROI-ranked futures competitions and a USD 50,000 Live Showdown for streaming creators.
The pattern: nearly every channel pays when followers trade, not when followers profit. A profit share only pays on gains, but fee commissions and rebates pay on every trade, win or lose. That is a design fact, not an accusation, yet it explains how a creator can look generous while being financially aligned with your activity rather than your results.
One more gap: when Binance launched its Live Trading Hub in May 2025 (verified creators with 1,000+ followers can stream while viewers place spot or futures trades inside the stream), it had not disclosed guardrails on creator liability or required disclaimers.
4. The reality of trading: what the numbers say
Brazil: among day traders who persisted more than 300 days, 97% lost money, and only about 1.1% earned more than minimum wage.Europe (CFDs): regulators found 74% to 89% of retail accounts lost money; UK broker disclosures show roughly 60% to 80%.Germany: BaFin found 74.2% of retail turbo-certificate traders lost money from 2019 to 2023, averaging €6,358 per loser and more than €3.4 billion in total.Bitcoin: BIS research reported in 2022 estimated that 73% to 81% of retail users likely lost money on their crypto investments.Influencer calls: a CoinWire study of X posts found 76% of promoted tokens later lost 90% or more of their value, and accounts above 200,000 followers promoted the worst performers (an average of −89% after three months). Binance’s gold badge starts at 30,000 followers.
How to read Binance’s own metrics:
ROI ignores account size and time.Win rate ignores payoff size; a 70% win rate can still lose money if the losses are bigger.Max drawdown is only as meaningful as the period it covers.Leverage matters more than most stats. Binance’s futures copy-trading launch included risk tags: yellow for 10x to 20x and red above 20x.Follower results differ from the leader’s because of fees, slippage and each follower’s own settings.
Independent and exchange-published analyses describe a wide gap between lead traders’ results and their followers’ results. There is no audited Binance dataset to confirm or refute that for Binance specifically, and that absence is itself a finding.
5. The controversy, sorted by strength of evidence
Documented in court filings
On March 31, 2023, a USD 1 billion lawsuit was filed in a Florida federal court against Binance, its then-CEO and three high-profile promoters (an NBA player and two YouTubers), alleging promotion of unregistered securities. These are plaintiffs’ allegations, not findings. Check the case’s current status before citing it.
Published investigations (allegations, not court findings)
Between November 5 and 9, 2026, on-chain analytics firm Bubblemaps alleged that some crypto traders attract followers with a visible wallet while selling from linked “side wallets.” In one case it alleged about USD 1.74 million was extracted through roughly 30 linked wallets since May 7, by selling into copy traders. In another it alleged side wallets bought before about 61% of a trader’s callouts and sold within minutes. Bubblemaps also criticized leaderboards, affiliate links and callout rewards for encouraging the behavior, and called for audits of top traders, disclosure of linked wallets and bans for repeat offenders. No public response from the trader in the USD 1.74 million case was found in the sources reviewed.Scope matters: these cases involve Solana memecoin traders. In the sources reviewed, none involve Binance Square creators or Binance copy trading. They matter here because the architecture is the same: a visible track record, a following and rewards for activity.
Disputed and unverified
On November 6 and 7, 2026, a celebrity-token promoter whose own history has been questioned by on-chain analysts published leaked chats claiming several well-known influencers took undisclosed payments to promote tokens in 2024. Those named dispute the claims, coverage notes that none of the payments is proven, and on-chain checks of at least one headline transfer have been challenged. Treat it as unproven.
What this means for Binance’s community
Trade Sharing Cards, Trader Profile and Smart Money are real improvements over screenshots.But no published Binance data on aggregate follower outcomes, no audit of top traders’ linked accounts and no disclosure rules for live-stream creators could be found. Those are the gaps the wider critique is pointing at.
6. A checklist before you follow any “verified” trader
Ask for absolute numbers: account size, realized P&L, max drawdown and days active, not ROI alone.Check leverage and liquidation history, not just the winning streak.Look for conflicts: are they earning Write to Earn commissions, referral fees or rebates on the trade they are promoting?Prefer verified trade cards over screenshots, and check whether holdings were disclosed when they posted.Compare a lead trader’s results with what followers actually received.Wait for a full market cycle, including a deep drawdown, before trusting a streak.Size every copy-trade or signal as money you can afford to lose.
Bottom line
“Verified” tells you who someone is. It doesn’t tell you what you would earn by following them. Binance’s newer tools make individual trades easier to check, but the platform still doesn’t publish how followers fare as a group, and most of the money flowing to creators depends on activity rather than outcomes. Until that changes, treat a badge as an ID check, not a track record.
What could not be verified
The number of active traders, verified creators or lead traders on Binance.Aggregate performance of copy-trading followers or leaderboard traders.The current status of the 2023 lawsuit.Whether any of the November 2026 allegations will be confirmed. They remain allegations.
Sources
Binance (official)
Binance Square verification checkmark: requirementsBinance Square FAQ (black vs gold checkmarks)Top Voices badgeSpot copy trading: lead trader requirementsFutures copy trading FAQLead Trader Growth PlanFutures Smart Money FAQTrader Profile (Binance blog, Feb 2025)Share Your Trades on Binance Square (Binance blog, May 2025)Write to Earn: up to 50% commission (Binance Square)Write to Earn: up to 30% (Binance Square, Aug 2024)
Company figures and coverage
Binance marks nine years (press release, July 14, 2026)Datawallet: Binance statistics for 2026Invezz: Binance at nine yearsBinance hits 300 million users (2025 User Pulse survey)MPost: Trader Profile launch and Square’s 35M monthly usersTraders Union: Trading BadgesCrypto Briefing: Live Trading HubThe Block: spot copy trading (April 2024)Benzinga: futures copy trading risk tagsThe Tribune: Traders League Season 4Taiwan News: Futures Traders League and Live ShowdownFortune: Binance’s influencer army (April 2023)Cointelegraph: USD 1 billion lawsuit (2023)CNN: Binance hack (October 30, 2026)
Studies on trader outcomes
Brazil day-trading study (summary on Binance Square)ESMA CFD loss rates (PR Newswire summary)Wolf Street: UK CFD loss ratesFinance Magnates: BaFin turbo-certificate studyThe Register: BIS analysis of crypto retail losses (2022)CoinWire influencer meme-coin study (via Binance Square)
Controversy coverage
TokenPost: Bubblemaps urges launchpads to audit top traderscrypto.news: Bubblemaps alleges hidden-wallet abuseKuCoin News: Bubblemaps and hidden walletsBubblemaps thread on X (November 9, 2026)La Sobremesa: the leaked-chats dispute
#HuangRisksOusterOverReportedAffairWithSubordinate #AnthropicRejectsIPODelayValuationinQuestion #ZcashFallsBelow$1000ForFirstTimeSinceSeptember #MSCIRemovalMayCurbStrategy’sBitcoinBuying #CanNvidiaEarningsEaseMarketConcerns?
M-O-N-A-R-C-H
·
--
Live + Verified Feature Only Be Accessible to Those who pass the Test.
Verified ≠ Profitable: Binance’s Traders, Verified Creators and the Reality Behind the Badge
Data as of November 12, 2026 · Educational research, not financial advice · Binance figures are company-reported and unaudited
The short version
Binance reports 323 million+ registered users, but its own 2025 survey found about half see themselves as long-term holders, not active traders. “Trader” is a far smaller group than the headline number.“Verified” on Binance can mean an identity check, a follower threshold, a performance snapshot or a lead-trader approval. None of them is an audited track record.Creators and lead traders are mostly paid on activity (followers’ trading fees, volume, ROI rankings), not on whether followers end up ahead.Studies from Brazil, Europe and the BIS keep finding that most retail leveraged traders lose money, and no public Binance dataset on how followers of verified traders actually perform could be found.In November 2026 on-chain analysts alleged that some crypto influencers sell from hidden “side wallets” into their own followers. The cases found are on Solana, not Binance, but the same mechanics exist wherever a visible trader has a following.Backdrop: Binance’s October 29 hack (reportedly about USD 6 billion, attributed by TRM Labs to a North Korea–linked group; Binance says user funds are safe) has put trust across the whole ecosystem under a microscope.
1. How many traders are there, really?
Users: 323 million+ registered users across 100+ countries as of July 14, 2026, which Binance says is roughly 43% of the ~741 million people who own crypto.Volume: about USD 34 trillion traded across products in 2025, plus roughly USD 11.4 trillion in the first half of 2026.Traders vs holders: in Binance’s 2025 User Pulse survey (95,000+ users in 48 markets), about half of users called themselves long-term holders rather than active traders.Binance Square: Binance described it as reaching 35 million+ monthly active users when it launched Trader Profile in early 2025.What isn’t public: no official count of active traders, verified creators or lead traders could be found. In 2024 a Binance spokesperson did not disclose what share of users had tried copy trading.
2. Five things “verified” can mean on Binance
KYC-verified account. Required to trade and to post on Square. It proves Binance knows who you are, and nothing about skill or honesty.Gold checkmark (Square). Identity verification, a completed profile and 30,000 followers on Square or major social channels. The “Verified+” tier adds 300,000 quarterly views or USD 1 million in Write to Earn volume, and status is reviewed every quarter. It proves identity, reach and activity, not performance. A black checkmark marks official Binance accounts, and separate “Top Voice” badges require regular article output (four articles in 30 days to qualify).Trader Profile and Trading Badges. An opt-in portfolio breakdown, P&L and badges tied to account performance. P&L is shown as a percentage only, with no absolute values, so +200% on USD 100 looks identical to +200% on USD 100,000.Smart Money (successor to the Futures Leaderboard). Shows the top 100 users who agreed to share their positions, and its stats exclude trading bots and copy trading. That is a self-selected top slice, a textbook setup for survivorship bias.Lead trader (copy trading). A verified account with a portfolio inside the allowed range (500 to 1,000,000 USDT on spot). It proves the trader meets Binance’s thresholds, not that followers profit.
In May 2025 Binance also added Trade Sharing Cards, which attach real spot and futures trades to posts in place of screenshots. That is a genuine step toward transparency, but it shows individual trades, not a full track record.
3. How verified traders get paid
Write to Earn: open to all KYC-verified users since early 2026. The base commission is 20% of the trading fees your readers generate, rising to as much as 50% for top-ranked weekly creators. In 2024 the ceiling was 30%.Copy trading: lead traders take a profit share (10% on spot; on futures it starts at 10% and can reach up to 30% on higher tiers) plus 10% of their followers’ trading fees.Affiliate links: in 2023 Fortune reported a network of about 26,000 Binance influencer-affiliates, with commissions of up to 40% of referred users’ fees and some earning over USD 1 million a year.Contests: Traders League campaigns have run multi-million-dollar prize pools (Season 4: about USD 4 million), including ROI-ranked futures competitions and a USD 50,000 Live Showdown for streaming creators.
The pattern: nearly every channel pays when followers trade, not when followers profit. A profit share only pays on gains, but fee commissions and rebates pay on every trade, win or lose. That is a design fact, not an accusation, yet it explains how a creator can look generous while being financially aligned with your activity rather than your results.
One more gap: when Binance launched its Live Trading Hub in May 2025 (verified creators with 1,000+ followers can stream while viewers place spot or futures trades inside the stream), it had not disclosed guardrails on creator liability or required disclaimers.
4. The reality of trading: what the numbers say
Brazil: among day traders who persisted more than 300 days, 97% lost money, and only about 1.1% earned more than minimum wage.Europe (CFDs): regulators found 74% to 89% of retail accounts lost money; UK broker disclosures show roughly 60% to 80%.Germany: BaFin found 74.2% of retail turbo-certificate traders lost money from 2019 to 2023, averaging €6,358 per loser and more than €3.4 billion in total.Bitcoin: BIS research reported in 2022 estimated that 73% to 81% of retail users likely lost money on their crypto investments.Influencer calls: a CoinWire study of X posts found 76% of promoted tokens later lost 90% or more of their value, and accounts above 200,000 followers promoted the worst performers (an average of −89% after three months). Binance’s gold badge starts at 30,000 followers.
How to read Binance’s own metrics:
ROI ignores account size and time.Win rate ignores payoff size; a 70% win rate can still lose money if the losses are bigger.Max drawdown is only as meaningful as the period it covers.Leverage matters more than most stats. Binance’s futures copy-trading launch included risk tags: yellow for 10x to 20x and red above 20x.Follower results differ from the leader’s because of fees, slippage and each follower’s own settings.
Independent and exchange-published analyses describe a wide gap between lead traders’ results and their followers’ results. There is no audited Binance dataset to confirm or refute that for Binance specifically, and that absence is itself a finding.
5. The controversy, sorted by strength of evidence
Documented in court filings
On March 31, 2023, a USD 1 billion lawsuit was filed in a Florida federal court against Binance, its then-CEO and three high-profile promoters (an NBA player and two YouTubers), alleging promotion of unregistered securities. These are plaintiffs’ allegations, not findings. Check the case’s current status before citing it.
Published investigations (allegations, not court findings)
Between November 5 and 9, 2026, on-chain analytics firm Bubblemaps alleged that some crypto traders attract followers with a visible wallet while selling from linked “side wallets.” In one case it alleged about USD 1.74 million was extracted through roughly 30 linked wallets since May 7, by selling into copy traders. In another it alleged side wallets bought before about 61% of a trader’s callouts and sold within minutes. Bubblemaps also criticized leaderboards, affiliate links and callout rewards for encouraging the behavior, and called for audits of top traders, disclosure of linked wallets and bans for repeat offenders. No public response from the trader in the USD 1.74 million case was found in the sources reviewed.Scope matters: these cases involve Solana memecoin traders. In the sources reviewed, none involve Binance Square creators or Binance copy trading. They matter here because the architecture is the same: a visible track record, a following and rewards for activity.
Disputed and unverified
On November 6 and 7, 2026, a celebrity-token promoter whose own history has been questioned by on-chain analysts published leaked chats claiming several well-known influencers took undisclosed payments to promote tokens in 2024. Those named dispute the claims, coverage notes that none of the payments is proven, and on-chain checks of at least one headline transfer have been challenged. Treat it as unproven.
What this means for Binance’s community
Trade Sharing Cards, Trader Profile and Smart Money are real improvements over screenshots.But no published Binance data on aggregate follower outcomes, no audit of top traders’ linked accounts and no disclosure rules for live-stream creators could be found. Those are the gaps the wider critique is pointing at.
6. A checklist before you follow any “verified” trader
Ask for absolute numbers: account size, realized P&L, max drawdown and days active, not ROI alone.Check leverage and liquidation history, not just the winning streak.Look for conflicts: are they earning Write to Earn commissions, referral fees or rebates on the trade they are promoting?Prefer verified trade cards over screenshots, and check whether holdings were disclosed when they posted.Compare a lead trader’s results with what followers actually received.Wait for a full market cycle, including a deep drawdown, before trusting a streak.Size every copy-trade or signal as money you can afford to lose.
Bottom line
“Verified” tells you who someone is. It doesn’t tell you what you would earn by following them. Binance’s newer tools make individual trades easier to check, but the platform still doesn’t publish how followers fare as a group, and most of the money flowing to creators depends on activity rather than outcomes. Until that changes, treat a badge as an ID check, not a track record.
What could not be verified
The number of active traders, verified creators or lead traders on Binance.Aggregate performance of copy-trading followers or leaderboard traders.The current status of the 2023 lawsuit.Whether any of the November 2026 allegations will be confirmed. They remain allegations.
Sources
Binance (official)
Binance Square verification checkmark: requirementsBinance Square FAQ (black vs gold checkmarks)Top Voices badgeSpot copy trading: lead trader requirementsFutures copy trading FAQLead Trader Growth PlanFutures Smart Money FAQTrader Profile (Binance blog, Feb 2025)Share Your Trades on Binance Square (Binance blog, May 2025)Write to Earn: up to 50% commission (Binance Square)Write to Earn: up to 30% (Binance Square, Aug 2024)
Company figures and coverage
Binance marks nine years (press release, July 14, 2026)Datawallet: Binance statistics for 2026Invezz: Binance at nine yearsBinance hits 300 million users (2025 User Pulse survey)MPost: Trader Profile launch and Square’s 35M monthly usersTraders Union: Trading BadgesCrypto Briefing: Live Trading HubThe Block: spot copy trading (April 2024)Benzinga: futures copy trading risk tagsThe Tribune: Traders League Season 4Taiwan News: Futures Traders League and Live ShowdownFortune: Binance’s influencer army (April 2023)Cointelegraph: USD 1 billion lawsuit (2023)CNN: Binance hack (October 30, 2026)
Studies on trader outcomes
Brazil day-trading study (summary on Binance Square)ESMA CFD loss rates (PR Newswire summary)Wolf Street: UK CFD loss ratesFinance Magnates: BaFin turbo-certificate studyThe Register: BIS analysis of crypto retail losses (2022)CoinWire influencer meme-coin study (via Binance Square)
Controversy coverage
TokenPost: Bubblemaps urges launchpads to audit top traderscrypto.news: Bubblemaps alleges hidden-wallet abuseKuCoin News: Bubblemaps and hidden walletsBubblemaps thread on X (November 9, 2026)La Sobremesa: the leaked-chats dispute
#HuangRisksOusterOverReportedAffairWithSubordinate #AnthropicRejectsIPODelayValuationinQuestion #ZcashFallsBelow$1000ForFirstTimeSinceSeptember #MSCIRemovalMayCurbStrategy’sBitcoinBuying #CanNvidiaEarningsEaseMarketConcerns?
Data as of November 12, 2026 · Educational research, not financial advice · Binance figures are company-reported and unaudited
The short version
Binance reports 323 million+ registered users, but its own 2025 survey found about half see themselves as long-term holders, not active traders. “Trader” is a far smaller group than the headline number.“Verified” on Binance can mean an identity check, a follower threshold, a performance snapshot or a lead-trader approval. None of them is an audited track record.Creators and lead traders are mostly paid on activity (followers’ trading fees, volume, ROI rankings), not on whether followers end up ahead.Studies from Brazil, Europe and the BIS keep finding that most retail leveraged traders lose money, and no public Binance dataset on how followers of verified traders actually perform could be found.In November 2026 on-chain analysts alleged that some crypto influencers sell from hidden “side wallets” into their own followers. The cases found are on Solana, not Binance, but the same mechanics exist wherever a visible trader has a following.Backdrop: Binance’s October 29 hack (reportedly about USD 6 billion, attributed by TRM Labs to a North Korea–linked group; Binance says user funds are safe) has put trust across the whole ecosystem under a microscope.
1. How many traders are there, really?
Users: 323 million+ registered users across 100+ countries as of July 14, 2026, which Binance says is roughly 43% of the ~741 million people who own crypto.Volume: about USD 34 trillion traded across products in 2025, plus roughly USD 11.4 trillion in the first half of 2026.Traders vs holders: in Binance’s 2025 User Pulse survey (95,000+ users in 48 markets), about half of users called themselves long-term holders rather than active traders.Binance Square: Binance described it as reaching 35 million+ monthly active users when it launched Trader Profile in early 2025.What isn’t public: no official count of active traders, verified creators or lead traders could be found. In 2024 a Binance spokesperson did not disclose what share of users had tried copy trading.
2. Five things “verified” can mean on Binance
KYC-verified account. Required to trade and to post on Square. It proves Binance knows who you are, and nothing about skill or honesty.Gold checkmark (Square). Identity verification, a completed profile and 30,000 followers on Square or major social channels. The “Verified+” tier adds 300,000 quarterly views or USD 1 million in Write to Earn volume, and status is reviewed every quarter. It proves identity, reach and activity, not performance. A black checkmark marks official Binance accounts, and separate “Top Voice” badges require regular article output (four articles in 30 days to qualify).Trader Profile and Trading Badges. An opt-in portfolio breakdown, P&L and badges tied to account performance. P&L is shown as a percentage only, with no absolute values, so +200% on USD 100 looks identical to +200% on USD 100,000.Smart Money (successor to the Futures Leaderboard). Shows the top 100 users who agreed to share their positions, and its stats exclude trading bots and copy trading. That is a self-selected top slice, a textbook setup for survivorship bias.Lead trader (copy trading). A verified account with a portfolio inside the allowed range (500 to 1,000,000 USDT on spot). It proves the trader meets Binance’s thresholds, not that followers profit.
In May 2025 Binance also added Trade Sharing Cards, which attach real spot and futures trades to posts in place of screenshots. That is a genuine step toward transparency, but it shows individual trades, not a full track record.
3. How verified traders get paid
Write to Earn: open to all KYC-verified users since early 2026. The base commission is 20% of the trading fees your readers generate, rising to as much as 50% for top-ranked weekly creators. In 2024 the ceiling was 30%.Copy trading: lead traders take a profit share (10% on spot; on futures it starts at 10% and can reach up to 30% on higher tiers) plus 10% of their followers’ trading fees.Affiliate links: in 2023 Fortune reported a network of about 26,000 Binance influencer-affiliates, with commissions of up to 40% of referred users’ fees and some earning over USD 1 million a year.Contests: Traders League campaigns have run multi-million-dollar prize pools (Season 4: about USD 4 million), including ROI-ranked futures competitions and a USD 50,000 Live Showdown for streaming creators.
The pattern: nearly every channel pays when followers trade, not when followers profit. A profit share only pays on gains, but fee commissions and rebates pay on every trade, win or lose. That is a design fact, not an accusation, yet it explains how a creator can look generous while being financially aligned with your activity rather than your results.
One more gap: when Binance launched its Live Trading Hub in May 2025 (verified creators with 1,000+ followers can stream while viewers place spot or futures trades inside the stream), it had not disclosed guardrails on creator liability or required disclaimers.
4. The reality of trading: what the numbers say
Brazil: among day traders who persisted more than 300 days, 97% lost money, and only about 1.1% earned more than minimum wage.Europe (CFDs): regulators found 74% to 89% of retail accounts lost money; UK broker disclosures show roughly 60% to 80%.Germany: BaFin found 74.2% of retail turbo-certificate traders lost money from 2019 to 2023, averaging €6,358 per loser and more than €3.4 billion in total.Bitcoin: BIS research reported in 2022 estimated that 73% to 81% of retail users likely lost money on their crypto investments.Influencer calls: a CoinWire study of X posts found 76% of promoted tokens later lost 90% or more of their value, and accounts above 200,000 followers promoted the worst performers (an average of −89% after three months). Binance’s gold badge starts at 30,000 followers.
How to read Binance’s own metrics:
ROI ignores account size and time.Win rate ignores payoff size; a 70% win rate can still lose money if the losses are bigger.Max drawdown is only as meaningful as the period it covers.Leverage matters more than most stats. Binance’s futures copy-trading launch included risk tags: yellow for 10x to 20x and red above 20x.Follower results differ from the leader’s because of fees, slippage and each follower’s own settings.
Independent and exchange-published analyses describe a wide gap between lead traders’ results and their followers’ results. There is no audited Binance dataset to confirm or refute that for Binance specifically, and that absence is itself a finding.
5. The controversy, sorted by strength of evidence
Documented in court filings
On March 31, 2023, a USD 1 billion lawsuit was filed in a Florida federal court against Binance, its then-CEO and three high-profile promoters (an NBA player and two YouTubers), alleging promotion of unregistered securities. These are plaintiffs’ allegations, not findings. Check the case’s current status before citing it.
Published investigations (allegations, not court findings)
Between November 5 and 9, 2026, on-chain analytics firm Bubblemaps alleged that some crypto traders attract followers with a visible wallet while selling from linked “side wallets.” In one case it alleged about USD 1.74 million was extracted through roughly 30 linked wallets since May 7, by selling into copy traders. In another it alleged side wallets bought before about 61% of a trader’s callouts and sold within minutes. Bubblemaps also criticized leaderboards, affiliate links and callout rewards for encouraging the behavior, and called for audits of top traders, disclosure of linked wallets and bans for repeat offenders. No public response from the trader in the USD 1.74 million case was found in the sources reviewed.Scope matters: these cases involve Solana memecoin traders. In the sources reviewed, none involve Binance Square creators or Binance copy trading. They matter here because the architecture is the same: a visible track record, a following and rewards for activity.
Disputed and unverified
On November 6 and 7, 2026, a celebrity-token promoter whose own history has been questioned by on-chain analysts published leaked chats claiming several well-known influencers took undisclosed payments to promote tokens in 2024. Those named dispute the claims, coverage notes that none of the payments is proven, and on-chain checks of at least one headline transfer have been challenged. Treat it as unproven.
What this means for Binance’s community
Trade Sharing Cards, Trader Profile and Smart Money are real improvements over screenshots.But no published Binance data on aggregate follower outcomes, no audit of top traders’ linked accounts and no disclosure rules for live-stream creators could be found. Those are the gaps the wider critique is pointing at.
6. A checklist before you follow any “verified” trader
Ask for absolute numbers: account size, realized P&L, max drawdown and days active, not ROI alone.Check leverage and liquidation history, not just the winning streak.Look for conflicts: are they earning Write to Earn commissions, referral fees or rebates on the trade they are promoting?Prefer verified trade cards over screenshots, and check whether holdings were disclosed when they posted.Compare a lead trader’s results with what followers actually received.Wait for a full market cycle, including a deep drawdown, before trusting a streak.Size every copy-trade or signal as money you can afford to lose.
Bottom line
“Verified” tells you who someone is. It doesn’t tell you what you would earn by following them. Binance’s newer tools make individual trades easier to check, but the platform still doesn’t publish how followers fare as a group, and most of the money flowing to creators depends on activity rather than outcomes. Until that changes, treat a badge as an ID check, not a track record.
What could not be verified
The number of active traders, verified creators or lead traders on Binance.Aggregate performance of copy-trading followers or leaderboard traders.The current status of the 2023 lawsuit.Whether any of the November 2026 allegations will be confirmed. They remain allegations.
Sources
Binance (official)
Binance Square verification checkmark: requirementsBinance Square FAQ (black vs gold checkmarks)Top Voices badgeSpot copy trading: lead trader requirementsFutures copy trading FAQLead Trader Growth PlanFutures Smart Money FAQTrader Profile (Binance blog, Feb 2025)Share Your Trades on Binance Square (Binance blog, May 2025)Write to Earn: up to 50% commission (Binance Square)Write to Earn: up to 30% (Binance Square, Aug 2024)
Company figures and coverage
Binance marks nine years (press release, July 14, 2026)Datawallet: Binance statistics for 2026Invezz: Binance at nine yearsBinance hits 300 million users (2025 User Pulse survey)MPost: Trader Profile launch and Square’s 35M monthly usersTraders Union: Trading BadgesCrypto Briefing: Live Trading HubThe Block: spot copy trading (April 2024)Benzinga: futures copy trading risk tagsThe Tribune: Traders League Season 4Taiwan News: Futures Traders League and Live ShowdownFortune: Binance’s influencer army (April 2023)Cointelegraph: USD 1 billion lawsuit (2023)CNN: Binance hack (October 30, 2026)
Studies on trader outcomes
Brazil day-trading study (summary on Binance Square)ESMA CFD loss rates (PR Newswire summary)Wolf Street: UK CFD loss ratesFinance Magnates: BaFin turbo-certificate studyThe Register: BIS analysis of crypto retail losses (2022)CoinWire influencer meme-coin study (via Binance Square)
Controversy coverage
TokenPost: Bubblemaps urges launchpads to audit top traderscrypto.news: Bubblemaps alleges hidden-wallet abuseKuCoin News: Bubblemaps and hidden walletsBubblemaps thread on X (November 9, 2026)La Sobremesa: the leaked-chats dispute
#HuangRisksOusterOverReportedAffairWithSubordinate #AnthropicRejectsIPODelayValuationinQuestion #ZcashFallsBelow$1000ForFirstTimeSinceSeptember #MSCIRemovalMayCurbStrategy’sBitcoinBuying #CanNvidiaEarningsEaseMarketConcerns?
Log in to explore more content