Nine U.S. Democratic senators have urged the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to reverse its latest directive to prediction market operators, escalating a regulatory dispute over whether platforms such as Kalshi and Polymarket can offer event contracts nationwide.

In a November 16 2026 letter to CFTC Chairman, Michael Selig, the lawmakers argued that the regulator’s November 5 2026 interpretation effectively requires exchanges to allow users in all 50 states to access prediction markets even where state authorities and courts have prohibited certain contracts.

The CFTC had given designated contract markets 30 days to remove geographic restrictions, commonly known as geofencing, or explain why they could not comply.

The senators say the directive conflicts with court orders requiring platforms to block certain prediction contracts in Michigan, Nevada, and Washington, as well as on the lands of two California tribes.

They also argue that sports-related event contracts should be subject to state and tribal gambling laws rather than treated exclusively as federally regulated derivatives.

 

“Your unilateral decision directly conflicts with active court orders, undermines state and tribal law, and must be reversed,” the lawmakers wrote.

 

REGULATION | New York Sues Polymarket Over Alleged ‘Illegal Gambling Operation’

 

The letter was signed by Adam Schiff, Amy Klobuchar, Maria Cantwell, Catherine Cortez Masto, Alex Padilla, Gary Peters, Jacky Rosen, Elissa Slotkin and Patty Murray.

The senators want the CFTC to withdraw its interpretation or suspend implementation until the ongoing litigation is resolved. They also asked the agency to explicitly protect geographic restrictions imposed by courts adopted to comply with tribal gaming laws or voluntarily introduced by exchanges.

The dispute adds another layer of regulatory uncertainty for prediction market operators which have increasingly challenged state authorities seeking to classify sports-related event contracts as illegal gambling.

The political pressure is also building. Democrats are set to take control of the Senate Agriculture Committee’s agenda in January 2027 giving them greater influence over congressional oversight of the CFTC.

The lawmakers have separately requested that the agency preserve all relevant communications and records dating back to January 2025 including emails, text messages, and communications through encrypted messaging applications.

They have requested a written response and confirmation that records are being preserved by November 23 2026.

The dispute highlights a central question for the prediction market industry – whether federal derivatives regulation can over-ride state gambling restrictions allowing platforms to operate nationally or whether states retain the authority to block products they consider illegal betting.

 

 

REGULATION | Kalshi Faces Criminal Charges and Civil Lawsuits as Prediction Market Legal Risks Escalate

 

 

 

 

 

Want to keep up with the latest news on crypto regulations globally?

Join our WhatsApp channel here.

Follow us on X for the latest posts and updates

Join and interact with our Telegram community

__________