Liquidation & Insurance Funds: How They Work and Why They Are Important to Crypto-Derivatives (Part 1)
Key Takeaways:
Futures exchanges have established various risk management mechanisms to protect highly leveraged traders from incurring significant losses.
Liquidation is a security feature that prevents traders from falling into negative equity.
Insurance funds are safety nets that protect bankrupt traders from adverse losses and ensure that the profits of winning traders are paid out in full.
This two-part series explains the intricacies of liquidation mechanisms and insurance funds in the crypto-derivatives industry. Part 1 begins by diving into the basics of a liquidation process and outlines the different stages of liquidation that an exchange may perform given varying market conditions. After that, it provides a brief introduction to insurance funds and how it is used to protect traders. Lastly, it explains how insurance funds grow.
In futures trading, traders can trade with leverage and are only required to fund the margin requirements to open positions in a futures contract. It is a key feature that makes the futures market attractive as it allows traders to profit from relatively small changes in price movement. Thus, leverage has the potential to magnify a trader’s profits or losses by the same magnitude.
How Liquidation Works
Futures exchanges have established various risk management mechanisms to protect highly leveraged traders from incurring significant losses. One of which is liquidation, a security feature that prevents traders from falling into negative equity.
In volatile markets, leveraged positions are prone to price gaps and may cause a trader’s equity to plunge into negative territory instantaneously. In these situations, losses can be larger than the trading margin. As a result, the losers are liquidated and may not have sufficient margin in their positions to pay the winners in full.
Here's an example of how liquidation plays out in real-life:
Consider two traders, Sally and John, both initiated opposing positions in BTC/USDT perpetual futures with 20x leverage. Table 1 describes the details of their respective positions.
Table 1 - Position details of Sally and John
Let’s assume a 5% increase in BTC prices to $8,400. In this scenario, Sally profits $8,000 on her long trade, while John loses $8,000 on his short trade. The consequent events are as follows:
John depletes his margin and is subjected to liquidation.
The price at which margin drops to zero is called the bankruptcy price. For John, $8,400 is the bankruptcy price.
Instantaneously, the exchange liquidates John’s position at $8,400 to ensure that Sally receives her profits.
In the volatile crypto market, it is extremely difficult to ensure that the losing positions are liquidated precisely at their bankruptcy price. Furthermore, liquidating beyond the bankruptcy price would mean that Sally receives fewer profits and John would incur more losses.
To prevent these occurrences, exchanges tend to liquidate the losing positions at a price better than the bankruptcy price, this is known as the liquidation price. The following diagram illustrates how this would work.
Diagram 1 - Short liquidation
Source: Binance Futures
Diagram 2: Long liquidation
Source: Binance Futures
Based on these illustrations, the exchange may liquidate John’s position at $8,300, which leaves a buffer of $100 to ensure that Sally’s profits are kept whole. Upon liquidation, John loses his margin and any remaining equity after funding Sally’s profits are transferred into an entity known as the Insurance Fund.
Stages of Liquidation
In cases where an exchange is unable to liquidate positions before a trader reaches negative equity, the following methods will be used to cover the losses of bankrupt positions:
Insurance Fund - A fund that is maintained by the exchange to ensure that profitable traders receive their profits in full and cover any excess losses incurred by a bankrupt trader.
Socialized Loss System - With this method, losses of bankrupt positions are distributed among all profitable traders.
Auto-Deleverage Liquidations (ADLs) - In ADLs, the exchange selects opposing traders in order of leverage and profitability, from which positions are automatically liquidated to cover the losing trader’s position.
What Is an Insurance Fund?
Insurance funds are safety nets that protect bankrupt traders from adverse losses and ensure that the profits of winning traders are paid out in full. The primary purpose of an insurance fund is to limit the occurrences of auto-deleverage liquidations (ADLs).
In ADLs, positions of opposing traders are automatically liquidated to cover for the losing trader’s position. In these situations, opposing profitable positions with high leverage are likely to receive auto-deleverage liquidations.
Insurance funds are contributions from liquidated positions. As long as the exchange can liquidate an order at a price better than the bankruptcy price, positive inflow goes into the insurance fund.
Diagram 3 - An illustration of net flows into the insurance fund
Source: Binance Futures
The insurance fund model is not exclusive to crypto derivatives exchanges. Traditional exchanges such as CME and CBOE also have safeguards systems that are larger than native cryptocurrency exchanges and can support multiple defaults. These safeguards systems involve several parties such as clearinghouses, clearing members, and typically demand higher collateral than unregulated exchanges.
Chart 1 - CME’s Base Financial Safeguards Package
Source: CME, Data as of September 30, 2019.
Chart 2 - IRS Financial Safeguards Package
Source: CME, Data as of September 30, 2019.
How Do Insurance Funds Grow?
As discussed, insurance funds grow from the contributions of liquidated accounts. The remainder equity of liquidated accounts, the spread between the liquidation price and the bankruptcy price, is kept in the insurance fund. This is shown in Diagram 4.
Diagram 4 - Spread between Liquidation Price and Bankruptcy Price contributes to Insurance Fund
Source: Binance Futures
Therefore, the wider the spread, the more inflows go into the insurance fund. Consequently, exchanges are incentivized to liquidate positions better than the liquidation price to avoid price slippage. This incentive may lead to aggressive liquidation practices by exchanges, further punishing its bankrupt traders.
Pros and Cons of Insurance Funds
Pros - In socialized loss systems and ADLs, positions of profitable traders are liquidated to offset the losses of bankrupt traders. These methods are extremely disruptive and punishing for traders who manage risk carefully. On the other hand, insurance funds aim to avoid these disruptive methods by forming a central entity that is designed to absorb excess losses.
Cons - Some insurance funds are not transparent and tend to grow uncontrollably. These undesirable factors stem from the inability or unwillingness of an exchange to provide clear rules in the event of liquidations, thus, leading to aggressive liquidation practices.
In Part 2 of this series, we dive deeper into the current state of insurance funds maintained by major exchanges. We also highlights the uniqueness of Binance Futures insurance fund as one of the most consumer protection driven fund in the industry.
Read the following helpful articles for more information about trading responsibly on Binance Futures:
(Support) How to Place Stop Loss Order and Take Profit Order
(Blog) How Binance Takes Responsible Trading Seriously, and You Should Too
(Blog) Crypto Spot vs. Crypto Futures Trading - What’s the Difference?
And many more Binance Futures FAQ topics...
Disclaimer: Crypto assets are volatile products with a high risk of losing money quickly. Prices can fluctuate significantly on any given day. Due to these price fluctuations, your holdings may significantly increase or decrease in value at any given moment, which can result in a loss of all the capital you have invested in a transaction.
Therefore, you should not trade or invest money you cannot afford to lose. It is crucial that you fully understand the risks involved before deciding to trade with us in light of your financial resources, level of experience, and risk appetite. If required, you should seek advice from an independent financial advisor. The actual returns and losses experienced by you will vary depending on many factors, including, but not limited to, market behavior, market movement, and your trade size. Past performance is not a guide to future performance. The value of your investments may go up or down. Learn more here.