If you lose $3 million to a casino, it's your fault.
If a casino loses $3 million to you, it's a software glitch.
A woman turned $50 into $3,289,500.75. The casino, state regulators, and two courts all tried to shut her down.
In March 2021, Jacqueline Davis opened BetMGM in Detroit and put $50 on an online game called Luck O' the Roulette.
She kept winning, pushed her bets up to the $5,000 table limit, and swung up and down across more than $11 million over five straight days.
When her balance hit $3,289,500.75, she stopped and asked to cash out.
At first, BetMGM congratulated her by email, and MGM Grand Detroit handed her $100,000 in cash as an advance.
The next day, she walked back in for the rest. That's when BetMGM locked her account, erased the remaining $3,189,500.75, and blamed a software malfunction.
Even weirder, Michigan rules required operators to check games every 24 hours. BetMGM kept taking $5,000 spins from her for five straight days without flagging a single problem.
Instead of paying, MGM sent an offer through her lawyer, David Steingold:
- Keep the $100,000 cash advance already paid
- Give up every dollar of the remaining $3,189,500.75
- Sign a confidentiality deal banning her from ever talking about the glitch
- Repay the $100,000 plus all of MGM's legal bills if word ever leaked
She refused to sign and went to state regulators.
The Michigan Gaming Control Board confirmed BetMGM didn't report the glitch on time, issued zero penalties, and sent Jacqueline 3 written replies saying regulators don't resolve disputes between casinos and players. She had to file a public records request just to learn her case was closed.
She sued in Wayne County Circuit Court. Both the trial judge and the Michigan Court of Appeals dismissed her case, ruling state law blocked players from suing online casinos directly.
Four years later, on July 22, 2025, the Michigan Supreme Court stepped in.
In a unanimous decision authored by Justice Brian K. Zahra, the court reversed both lower rulings and cleared Jacqueline Davis to take BetMGM to trial.
Funny how glitches only break one way.