CarMax and Carvana are competing for leadership in the U.S. used-car market, with their strategies reflecting a broader debate over whether customers prefer online shopping or in-person visits. According to Sina Finance, CarMax is emphasizing its physical stores while upgrading its digital services, whereas Carvana’s business is built around buying cars online.
CarMax, the country’s largest used-car retailer, operates 260 stores and also sells vehicles online. CEO Keith Barr says the company will improve its existing model rather than shift to online-only sales, arguing that most customers still visit stores to test-drive cars. Carvana CEO Ernie Garcia III said on last month’s earnings call that his company was close to becoming the nation’s largest used-car retailer. Stephens analyst Jeff Leick said Barr was wise to adopt competitors’ effective ideas.
U.S. used-car retail sales total about 20 million vehicles a year, representing a market worth roughly $550 billion, according to Cox Automotive. CarMax and Carvana together account for less than 10% of the market. New-car prices have climbed to about $50,000, while insurance and repair costs have also risen. The number of new-car buyers is about 1 million below its pre-pandemic level and is not expected to recover in the near term.
CarMax’s vehicle sales peaked at 924,000 in the fiscal year ended February 28, 2022, then fell to 766,000 two years later. After several years of declining sales, the company parted ways with former CEO Bill Nash in 2025 and has carried out three rounds of layoffs over the past year. Barr, whose background is in the hotel industry, was hired in part for his experience strengthening digital capabilities at InterContinental Hotels Group.
CarMax plans to digitize vehicle reconditioning and expand its standalone reconditioning centers, which it began opening in 2024. It also aims to improve vehicle logistics and grow its auto-financing business. Carvana uses dedicated reconditioning sites and proprietary software, a hub-and-spoke logistics network, and financing for 85% of its sales orders, with loans subsequently sold to banks and investors.
Doug Hall, a CarMax customer who has also sold a car to Carvana, said he prefers to see and test-drive a used car before buying. Carvana offers a seven-day return policy, and its vehicle vending towers serve as delivery locations for online purchases.
