28 billion dollars “forced to sell” is an old number. The real problem with MSTR is not the day of November 30 — its money-printing machine had already stopped first.
On November 11, MSCI confirmed: after the close on November 30, it will remove Strategy ($MSTR ) from the MSCI USA Index, and under the new rules it counts as a “non-operating company.”
JPMorgan’s 2.8 billion dollars was an estimate from last November based on the old scheme; Strategy itself calculated that funds tracking MSCI hold only about 13 million shares. At Friday’s closing price of 77.80 dollars, that is about 1 billion dollars, less than half of Friday’s daily trading volume of 35.7 million shares.
On Friday, MSTR closed at 77.80 dollars, down 9.7% in one day, down 30% in five days, and down 47% in one month. Its holdings of 850,849 BTC cost 64.2 billion dollars, with an average price of 75,452 dollars; at the current price of about 60,800 dollars, they are worth only about 51.7 billion dollars, with an unrealized loss on the books of about 12.5 billion dollars.
Its 12% preferred stock STRC closed on Friday at 93.60 dollars, falling below the 100-dollar par value.
My view is that the key is not the forced selling on November 30, but mNAV: based on Friday’s close, the enterprise-value-based mNAV is about 0.95x, already below 1; and the management team’s own share-issuance Bitcoin-buying break-even line set in May is 1.22x — below this number, every share issued to buy Bitcoin dilutes existing shareholders.
Last week’s actions already show the problem: that week, 244.7 million dollars of common stock was sold, while buying back STRC cost 228 million dollars and only 485 BTC were bought (33.4 million dollars). ATM proceeds are first going to plug the hole in preferred stock, no longer ammunition for buying Bitcoin.
Next, watch two variables: first, whether other index providers will follow MSCI (JPMorgan’s old estimate said that if they do, it would add another 8.8 billion dollars), and second, whether mNAV can get back above 1.22x — if not, November 30 is only the beginning.
Do you think MSTR now looks more like a wrongly sold-off BTC leveraged play, or a financing machine that has already stopped turning? If BTC returns above 70,000 dollars and mNAV returns to 1.22x, can Saylor’s strategy still get going again?
$BTC $MSTR
#比特币 #Strategy #MSCI #mNAV
The above is only a summary of market information and does not constitute investment advice.
On November 11, MSCI confirmed: after the close on November 30, it will remove Strategy ($MSTR ) from the MSCI USA Index, and under the new rules it counts as a “non-operating company.”
JPMorgan’s 2.8 billion dollars was an estimate from last November based on the old scheme; Strategy itself calculated that funds tracking MSCI hold only about 13 million shares. At Friday’s closing price of 77.80 dollars, that is about 1 billion dollars, less than half of Friday’s daily trading volume of 35.7 million shares.
On Friday, MSTR closed at 77.80 dollars, down 9.7% in one day, down 30% in five days, and down 47% in one month. Its holdings of 850,849 BTC cost 64.2 billion dollars, with an average price of 75,452 dollars; at the current price of about 60,800 dollars, they are worth only about 51.7 billion dollars, with an unrealized loss on the books of about 12.5 billion dollars.
Its 12% preferred stock STRC closed on Friday at 93.60 dollars, falling below the 100-dollar par value.
My view is that the key is not the forced selling on November 30, but mNAV: based on Friday’s close, the enterprise-value-based mNAV is about 0.95x, already below 1; and the management team’s own share-issuance Bitcoin-buying break-even line set in May is 1.22x — below this number, every share issued to buy Bitcoin dilutes existing shareholders.
Last week’s actions already show the problem: that week, 244.7 million dollars of common stock was sold, while buying back STRC cost 228 million dollars and only 485 BTC were bought (33.4 million dollars). ATM proceeds are first going to plug the hole in preferred stock, no longer ammunition for buying Bitcoin.
Next, watch two variables: first, whether other index providers will follow MSCI (JPMorgan’s old estimate said that if they do, it would add another 8.8 billion dollars), and second, whether mNAV can get back above 1.22x — if not, November 30 is only the beginning.
Do you think MSTR now looks more like a wrongly sold-off BTC leveraged play, or a financing machine that has already stopped turning? If BTC returns above 70,000 dollars and mNAV returns to 1.22x, can Saylor’s strategy still get going again?
$BTC $MSTR
#比特币 #Strategy #MSCI #mNAV
The above is only a summary of market information and does not constitute investment advice.