On November 30, MSCI will kick MSTR out. The real killer isn’t the forced $2.8 billion in selling—it’s that Saylor’s machine for issuing shares to buy bitcoin has stopped turning.

On November 11, MSCI confirmed that it would remove MSTR from the MSCI USA Index after the market close on November 30, requiring index-tracking funds to sell before the close. Last year, JPMorgan estimated that the forced selling would amount to about $2.8 billion.
But Strategy itself says that funds tracking MSCI hold only about 13 million shares, or 3.1% of the total. At Friday’s closing price of $77.80, those shares are worth only about $1 billion—the $2.8 billion figure was an old estimate from last year, and the stock’s decline has already wiped out more than half of it.
MSTR closed Friday at $77.80, down 9.67% for the day, 32% over five trading days, and 49% over the past month. $BTC is currently around $59,531, up about 2.9% in 24 hours.
By today’s measure, MSTR’s market cap is only about 0.71 times the value of the bitcoin it holds—its market cap is about 29% below the value of its bitcoin.

My view: The key issue isn’t the MSCI move itself. It’s that once mNAV falls below 1, the business of issuing shares to buy bitcoin goes into reverse: the money raised by issuing a new share is no longer enough to cover the value of the bitcoin backing it, so every new issuance causes more dilution.
The week of November 2–8 is proof: the company raised $283.8 million by selling shares, but only $81.9 million (less than a third) went toward buying 1,036 bitcoin. The remaining $188.3 million went to repurchasing 12% of its STRC preferred stock—the preferred shares came first, and bitcoin buying took a back seat.
MSCI’s removal won’t force Strategy to sell a single bitcoin; it puts pressure on the stock price. The stock price puts pressure on its financing premium. Without that premium, the money to buy bitcoin dries up.

Keep an eye on three numbers next: MSTR’s trading volume and closing price around the November 30 close; whether STRC keeps sliding (it has already fallen below $96, versus its $100 par value); and whether the share of ATM proceeds going toward bitcoin purchases recovers in next week’s announcement.
If mNAV can’t get back above 1, Saylor’s roughly $4.9 billion in cash-like assets will cover only 3.4 years of interest and dividends, and bitcoin purchases will have to stop. At that point, MSTR will no longer be a “bitcoin amplifier,” but a leveraged bitcoin stock trading at a discount.

Do you think MSTR is “discounted bitcoin” right now, or “leveraged bitcoin liabilities”? If mNAV stays below 1 for a long time, should Saylor keep issuing shares to buy bitcoin?

#比特币 #MSTR #MSCI #US Stocks
The above is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.