On Kraken, $BTC traded at 24,250 Canadian dollars this Saturday, 21/11, while it was worth around C$82,000 everywhere else. No hack, according to the exchange: a CAD order book went haywire for 14 hours, and the trades stand.
The sequence, according to Kraken's public API (1-hour candles):
Fri. 20/11, ~20:00 UTC: โheavy selling pressureโ on CAD pairs (Kraken Support). USD/CAD, around 1.43, drops below 1.40.
Midnight: USD/CAD at 1.04.
Sat. 21/11, 08:00 UTC: the low. USD/CAD at 0.30, BTC/CAD at C$24,250, $ETH at C$796, USDC/CAD at 0.49. On BTC/USD at Kraken, bitcoin traded between $57,277 and $58,030 during the same hour. Difference: about -70%.
From ~10:00 UTC: back toward the market. This Sunday, BTC/CAD is around C$83,900.
Saturday, 11:12 UTC: Kraken Support writes on X that every order was processed correctly, with no breach. โExecuted trades stand.โ
The volume says it all: ~592 BTC traded on BTC/CAD between 20:00 and 10:00 UTC, compared with ~14 BTC per hour just before.
My take: bitcoin wasn't worth C$24,250; the internal USD/CAD rate gave way, and arbitrage spread it to all CAD pairs. Adam Back also points to USDC/CAD breaking away from the actual foreign exchange market (via PANews).
The lesson is simple: a market order on an illiquid fiat pair, in the middle of a panic, can go anywhere. Use a limit order, take a look at the order book, and be wary when the displayed price drifts away from the global price.
For context: $BTC hit $55,130 on Binance on Saturday and is trading at $59,111 this Sunday around 08:00 UTC (+2.2% over 24h).
Two possible outcomes: a technical explanation from Kraken closes the matter, or affected sellers challenge it and the debate over cancellations returns.
If you'd sold at C$24,250, would you consider it fair for the trade to stand?
#Kraken #Bitcoin
The sequence, according to Kraken's public API (1-hour candles):
Fri. 20/11, ~20:00 UTC: โheavy selling pressureโ on CAD pairs (Kraken Support). USD/CAD, around 1.43, drops below 1.40.
Midnight: USD/CAD at 1.04.
Sat. 21/11, 08:00 UTC: the low. USD/CAD at 0.30, BTC/CAD at C$24,250, $ETH at C$796, USDC/CAD at 0.49. On BTC/USD at Kraken, bitcoin traded between $57,277 and $58,030 during the same hour. Difference: about -70%.
From ~10:00 UTC: back toward the market. This Sunday, BTC/CAD is around C$83,900.
Saturday, 11:12 UTC: Kraken Support writes on X that every order was processed correctly, with no breach. โExecuted trades stand.โ
The volume says it all: ~592 BTC traded on BTC/CAD between 20:00 and 10:00 UTC, compared with ~14 BTC per hour just before.
My take: bitcoin wasn't worth C$24,250; the internal USD/CAD rate gave way, and arbitrage spread it to all CAD pairs. Adam Back also points to USDC/CAD breaking away from the actual foreign exchange market (via PANews).
The lesson is simple: a market order on an illiquid fiat pair, in the middle of a panic, can go anywhere. Use a limit order, take a look at the order book, and be wary when the displayed price drifts away from the global price.
For context: $BTC hit $55,130 on Binance on Saturday and is trading at $59,111 this Sunday around 08:00 UTC (+2.2% over 24h).
Two possible outcomes: a technical explanation from Kraken closes the matter, or affected sellers challenge it and the debate over cancellations returns.
If you'd sold at C$24,250, would you consider it fair for the trade to stand?
#Kraken #Bitcoin
