BTC has rebounded, but the biggest Bitcoin-buying machine has already gone into reverse—Strategy’s mNAV has fallen below 1, which, by management’s own rules, means it should be selling coins rather than buying them.

MSTR closed Friday at $77.80, down 9.67% for the day, after hitting a 52-week low of $77.69 intraday. It fell 32% over five trading days, while BTC was down only about 9% over the same period.
It holds 850,849 BTC, worth about $50.5 billion at the current price of $59,411, with an average cost of $75,452 and an unrealized loss of about $13.7 billion. The company’s market cap is about $32.9 billion, just around 65% of the value of its Bitcoin holdings.
The key is mNAV: enterprise value divided by the value of its Bitcoin holdings is about 0.98x, while management’s own breakeven threshold, set in May, is 1.22x. Below that threshold, issuing shares to buy Bitcoin dilutes shareholders, while selling Bitcoin to pay down debt actually increases their value.
Last week, it sold $244.7 million worth of stock and spent $206.3 million buying back preferred shares, but used only $33.4 million to buy Bitcoin. The buying machine has effectively stopped.
A more certain blow comes on November 30: MSCI’s removal takes effect at the close, and JPMorgan estimates that about $2.8 billion in passive selling will have to be executed. Preferred shares STRC have also fallen below $96 (par value: $100).
My take: MSTR has a beta of 3.8, so about half of its steeper decline compared with Bitcoin is due to leverage. But mNAV falling below 1 and the MSCI removal can’t be explained by beta—that’s a repricing of the Bitcoin treasury model itself. Two scenarios: if mNAV climbs back above 1.22, it means the market believes in the Bitcoin treasury model again, and the buying machine restarts; if it can’t, the passive selling on November 30 comes first, and Strategy shifts from a “Bitcoin price amplifier” to a “drag on Bitcoin’s price.” Keep an eye on three numbers: the actual volume of selling on November 30, how many shares it sells and how much Bitcoin it buys in each weekly 8-K, and whether mNAV can return to 1.22.
Now that mNAV has fallen below 1, would you still dare to treat MSTR as leveraged BTC?$BTC #比特币 #Strategy #MSCI
The above is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.