Prediction markets came under fire from both sides of Congress this week, and both sides struck hard.
On November 19, the Senate passed the Death Bets Act by voice vote. It would prohibit licensed platforms from listing contracts related to war, terrorist attacks, assassinations, or the deaths of individuals. The bill has been sent to the House of Representatives. On the same day, Representatives Carsten and Ted Lieu introduced H.R. 11092, which would establish a whistleblower program at the Department of Justice: anyone who reports insider trading in prediction markets that is substantiated and results in a fine of more than $1 million could receive 10% to 30% of the fine. Whistleblowers could remain anonymous, and employers would be prohibited from retaliating against them.
This isn’t about killing prediction markets—it’s about setting rules for them. Over the past 30 days, three platforms, including Kalshi and Polymarket, recorded a nominal trading volume of $136.77 billion, up 40.9% from the previous month. Kalshi alone accounted for 84%. The total for the year so far is $586 billion, 16.2 times last year’s figure. At this scale, Washington can no longer pretend not to notice.
The two bills take opposite approaches—one bans, the other rewards—and the thinking is actually quite clear: the ban targets the most outrageous categories, while the reward is for people who expose insider trading. Insider trading on prediction markets is much easier to catch than on the stock market: the platforms’ ledgers are public, so it’s easy to trace who placed a bet first and where the money came from. Kalshi has even admitted as much. The House Oversight Committee began investigating suspicious bets back in May, involving military operations and Trump’s remarks. The fuse had been lit long ago.
The real things to watch are still ahead: whether the bill can pass the House, how the lawsuit between the CFTC and Louisiana is decided, and whether the “prediction market contracts fall under the CFTC’s exclusive jurisdiction” position championed by Coinbase can be put into practice. Compliance costs will certainly rise, making things harder for smaller platforms. Larger platforms, on the other hand, may gain an even bigger legitimacy premium as a result. On-chain markets are still beyond the reach of regulators for now, but prediction markets are crypto’s most credible real-world use case. How their regulatory framework is set will, in turn, determine whether investors dare to put money in during the next cycle.
Do you think contracts that let people bet on war and human lives should be banned? Or would a ban just drive demand somewhere even darker?