$BTC $ETH $ZEC
The widely circulated “$2.9 billion in ETF outflows in November” is off by one word: it was 1 fund, not 12.
【First, the version going around】The two lines making the rounds most furiously overnight: one said “U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs saw net outflows of about $2.9 billion in November,” and the other, “the figure is already close to $3.5 billion.” A $600 million difference was called “conflicting data,” with two articles citing one figure each.
【What’s wrong】The $2.9 billion figure isn’t for the whole market; it’s for just one fund, BlackRock’s IBIT. According to SoSoValue, through the November 19 close: IBIT had net outflows of $2.94 billion in November, while all 12 U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs combined had outflows of $3.47 billion, equivalent to about 49,400 BTC. 2.94 ÷ 3.47 = 84.7%. There’s no contradiction between the two figures; one denominator is 1, the other is 12.
If you write “the whole market,” you must specify 12 funds and $3.47 billion. If you write “a single fund,” you must name IBIT and give its 85% share. Of the $582.2 million outflow on November 19 alone, IBIT accounted for $541.1 million (93%); FBTC, in second place, accounted for just $45.9 million—a single fund’s redemptions dragged the whole curve down.
【What matters more than the numbers】There were only 2 days of net inflows in the entire month’s 14 trading days (11-04 and 11-16, totaling $82.5 million). But Morgan Stanley’s MSBT bucked the trend with $49.6 million in inflows, bringing cumulative inflows since launch to $888 million. The same headline, “$3.47 billion in outflows,” contains two things: “one firm is exiting, another is building a position.” Leave one out, and it’s no longer news.
While we’re at it, let’s clear up a second trap: “$3.11 billion in net outflows year to date” and “more than $2.5 billion” are figures from the same dataset with different cutoff dates. Don’t use one to verify the other.
【Market snapshot】BTC 58,338.21 (-6.114%), 24-hour range 57,778.35–62,639.52; ZEC 733.18 (-17.478%), breaking below last night’s low of 745.88 to set a new low of 731.56; among five coins, only ZEC has a positive funding rate at +0.001954%, while BTC’s -0.004743% continues to deepen. My plan: only place a short if the rebound fails at 58,800; add only if it closes below 57,737.35; stop-loss at 59,600; don’t chase the current price.
Numbers don’t lie; it’s the people repeating them who keep changing the denominator.
“Three years to craft two lines; one recitation, and tears stream down both cheeks.” — Jia Dao, “After Writing a Poem”
Of IBIT’s 85% share of these $3.47 billion in outflows, do you think institutions are pulling out, or are basis traders closing their positions? Pick a side, and include your position size, leverage, and stop-loss so I know how much money backs that claim.
If you want to check the figures together in person, tap the group chat link on my profile: Eagle Strikes the Sky · Crypto Study Group—setting the record straight on misreported numbers.
The widely circulated “$2.9 billion in ETF outflows in November” is off by one word: it was 1 fund, not 12.
【First, the version going around】The two lines making the rounds most furiously overnight: one said “U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs saw net outflows of about $2.9 billion in November,” and the other, “the figure is already close to $3.5 billion.” A $600 million difference was called “conflicting data,” with two articles citing one figure each.
【What’s wrong】The $2.9 billion figure isn’t for the whole market; it’s for just one fund, BlackRock’s IBIT. According to SoSoValue, through the November 19 close: IBIT had net outflows of $2.94 billion in November, while all 12 U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs combined had outflows of $3.47 billion, equivalent to about 49,400 BTC. 2.94 ÷ 3.47 = 84.7%. There’s no contradiction between the two figures; one denominator is 1, the other is 12.
If you write “the whole market,” you must specify 12 funds and $3.47 billion. If you write “a single fund,” you must name IBIT and give its 85% share. Of the $582.2 million outflow on November 19 alone, IBIT accounted for $541.1 million (93%); FBTC, in second place, accounted for just $45.9 million—a single fund’s redemptions dragged the whole curve down.
【What matters more than the numbers】There were only 2 days of net inflows in the entire month’s 14 trading days (11-04 and 11-16, totaling $82.5 million). But Morgan Stanley’s MSBT bucked the trend with $49.6 million in inflows, bringing cumulative inflows since launch to $888 million. The same headline, “$3.47 billion in outflows,” contains two things: “one firm is exiting, another is building a position.” Leave one out, and it’s no longer news.
While we’re at it, let’s clear up a second trap: “$3.11 billion in net outflows year to date” and “more than $2.5 billion” are figures from the same dataset with different cutoff dates. Don’t use one to verify the other.
【Market snapshot】BTC 58,338.21 (-6.114%), 24-hour range 57,778.35–62,639.52; ZEC 733.18 (-17.478%), breaking below last night’s low of 745.88 to set a new low of 731.56; among five coins, only ZEC has a positive funding rate at +0.001954%, while BTC’s -0.004743% continues to deepen. My plan: only place a short if the rebound fails at 58,800; add only if it closes below 57,737.35; stop-loss at 59,600; don’t chase the current price.
Numbers don’t lie; it’s the people repeating them who keep changing the denominator.
“Three years to craft two lines; one recitation, and tears stream down both cheeks.” — Jia Dao, “After Writing a Poem”
Of IBIT’s 85% share of these $3.47 billion in outflows, do you think institutions are pulling out, or are basis traders closing their positions? Pick a side, and include your position size, leverage, and stop-loss so I know how much money backs that claim.
If you want to check the figures together in person, tap the group chat link on my profile: Eagle Strikes the Sky · Crypto Study Group—setting the record straight on misreported numbers.