How much will funds tracking that index actually have to sell? This question has been hanging over the market for a whole month, and estimates from different sides vary by several multiples. I laid out and compared several sets of figures, and the more I looked, the more I felt that people were really arguing about two different things. $BNB

The company’s own filing put the figure at about 13 million shares, or 3.1% of its basic shares outstanding. At the time, that was worth $1.6 billion—less than its usual trading volume in a single day. $CL

A major bank offered a much larger estimate, putting the selling pressure at $2.8 billion. If other index providers followed suit and changed their rules, it could reach $8.8 billion. But that estimate was based on an earlier proposal and doesn’t match the version that was ultimately adopted. $XAU

Put the two estimates side by side: one says the market can absorb the selling without a problem; the other says it could unleash tens of billions in sales. What’s the difference? One counts the shares that funds tracking this index would have to sell; the other also includes money from rebalancing by other index providers. They’re using different denominators, so they’re not really arguing about the same thing.

Another camp says this has already been priced in. The stock did fall on the day the rules were finalized, but it had already dropped nearly 20% over the previous month, so most investors who wanted out had likely already left. When the rebalancing actually happens, the sell orders may well be absorbed.

The other camp is focused on what comes next. Without this pool of price-insensitive buyers, it will be harder for the company to keep its premium-share issuance and crypto-buying machine running. What’s being cut off is the financing base of the whole business.

I’ve gone over these figures twice. Every estimate has a plausible rationale, but none offers evidence strong enough to rule out the others. The only thing we can be sure of is the date: it takes effect at the close on the 30th, and the new list goes live the following day.

Those figures will stay on the screen until trading over those few days gives us the answer. Until then, every number being quoted is still just an estimate.

These are my personal views and not investment advice. You are responsible for your own gains and losses.
#CapitalGroup increases its stake in Strategy by 1.2645 million shares