The rule announced on October 15 kept the company with the world’s largest cryptocurrency holdings out of the index. The new rules target non-operating companies: if their assets don’t support their business operations, they must pass five additional financial-ratio tests. Failing four or more means losing eligibility. $ETH

Companies already in the index get a two-period grace period. They’re only removed after failing the screening in two consecutive reporting periods. So this isn’t a sudden change of heart—the rules were there all along. $SOL

Several others were removed at the same time. The Tokyo-based company that holds crypto, and one that holds a different cryptocurrency as a reserve asset, are both on the list. Another company with an Ethereum treasury is on the watchlist. $CL

Why are these companies grouped together? Their financial statements tell the story. Net income swung wildly over three quarters: a loss of 12.54 billion in Q1, a loss of 8.22 billion in Q2, then a profit of 19.53 billion in Q3. Almost all of that volatility came from marking their cryptocurrency holdings to market, with little to do with their software business.

The software business is much steadier. Quarterly revenue has stayed in a narrow range of 111 million to 128 million for two years. Yet this company holds 850,364 coins on its balance sheet, purchased at an average price of 75,456.

The index provider’s job is to maintain investability. Keeping companies like these in a broad-market index would effectively make passive investors bear the volatility of crypto prices. The line is drawn based on structure, not aimed at any particular company.

The change takes effect after the market closes on November 30. From then on, funds tracking the index will have to rebalance according to the new list. How much they sell—and whether the market can absorb it—is another matter.

After going through those thresholds, it feels more like a reclassification of a type of company. Call it a business or a fund, and you end up using a different yardstick to value it.

These are my personal views and not investment advice. You are responsible for your own gains and losses.
#CapitalGroup adds 1.2645 million shares of Strategy stock