At 3 a.m. Beijing time today, the Fed released the minutes from its October meeting. The wording was anything but ambiguous: “almost all participants” thought further rate hikes would likely be appropriate; two also mentioned that if inflation data came in looking bad, the Fed could consider a hike of more than 25 basis points in December. Before the minutes came out, Governor Waller put it even more bluntly on CNBC: the Fed should consider a 50-basis-point hike in December—“we may have to give people a bit of a shock.”
How did Bitcoin react? It was around 63,100 when the minutes were released, then hit a low of 62,570 over the next hour. At 6 a.m., it dipped to 62,062—just over 50 points above the weekend low of 62,006, but it held. Then it climbed steadily back, and is now around 63,800. The 10-year Treasury yield closed at 5.07% yesterday, a little lower than the previous day’s 5.10%.
It’s not that the market isn’t afraid of rate hikes; it’s that it’s heard all this before. A 25-basis-point hike in December is already almost fully priced in by futures. Bitcoin has fallen more than 20% from its high of 81,823 on October 28, the day of the Fed meeting, to where it is now. In my view, a good part of that drop is the market pricing in this very message ahead of time: “More hikes are coming.”
One thing to note: the minutes also contain a passage few people looked at closely. Most participants noted that AI-related debt is growing rapidly, and much of it is being financed through “complex and opaque financing structures.” Yesterday, everyone was applauding Nvidia’s doubled revenue, while the Fed had already been discussing this kind of debt as a financial-stability risk in its meeting room at the end of October.
Soros wrote this in The Alchemy of Finance, a line highlighted by 869 people on WeRead:
“The market will react to investors’ expectations, and investors’ feelings will in turn lead to changes in prices. This trend validates itself through a process of repeated self-reinforcement, until some unexpected event shakes investors’ expectations.”
Look at this in today’s context, and the quote has two layers. First, over the past few weeks, the expectation that “the Fed will keep raising rates” has been reinforcing itself: prices fall, sentiment turns cold, and cold sentiment makes people more willing to believe the next hawkish headline. Minutes filled with talk of rate hikes merely confirmed that expectation, so when they landed, the market only felt the pain for one morning.
The second layer matters more: what can shake expectations is an unexpected event, not known bad news. Right now, everyone is betting on 25 basis points, while Waller, of all people, has publicly said he wants to deliver a shock. A 50-basis-point hike in December, or a sudden reversal in inflation data, would be the kind of thing that changes the direction—either way.
A bit of self-deprecation: the most common mistake in a bear market is treating every piece of bad news as new and panicking all over again. I’m still bullish on Bitcoin’s long-term direction, and my stance tonight is simple: don’t pay tuition twice for what’s already priced in; what isn’t priced in is what’s worth watching.