According to Jin10, investors are increasingly questioning gold’s traditional role as a safe-haven asset in portfolios. In recent months, gold prices have fallen sharply even as risk assets such as stocks suffered steep sell-offs. George Cheveley, a portfolio manager at Ninety One, said gold had performed “more like a risk asset” than a hedge against risk.

Peel Hunt analysts said there was “no clear trigger” for gold’s fall to a new low this week; falling oil prices and bond yields should, in fact, have supported gold. They added that the price break below $3,800 per ounce looked like “potential capitulation selling” by investors. This raised concerns that market sentiment was deteriorating and that more investors saw a need to close positions and stay on the sidelines as the new year approached.

John Reade, the World Gold Council’s strategist for Asian and European markets, said this year’s weakness in gold was “largely due to leveraged Western speculators and investors”—short-term participants who entered as prices rose rapidly and exited quickly when economic conditions changed. Helen Amos, managing director and commodities analyst at the Bank of Montreal, said investors had warned that they no longer viewed gold as a diversification tool in stock portfolios.