The crypto treasury business is losing steam. After reviewing five digital asset treasury companies, Protos found that most underperformed the tokens they hold. Some even saw their market caps fall below the value of their holdings, as the once-popular “buy tokens and the price will rise” logic starts to fail.

Industry leader Strategy is an exception: since its first Bitcoin purchase in August 2020, its share price has risen 615%, outperforming Bitcoin’s 461% gain over the same period. But it has fallen 80% from its November 2024 peak. It currently holds 850,849 bitcoins, more than 4% of the total mined, and has an mNAV of just 0.75x—meaning its market cap is now below the value of its Bitcoin holdings. It also sold 5,553 bitcoins between July and August this year. Its software business brings in only about $100 million in quarterly revenue, far less than the gains or losses driven by Bitcoin’s price swings.

The other end looks even bleaker: Tron Inc, whose chairman is Justin Sun’s father, has fallen 85% since its pivot, while TRX has actually risen 12% over the same period. The share price is down about 87% from its peak, though its mNAV is still 2.77x. Tether-linked Twenty One has fallen 61% since listing last December, while Bitcoin is down just 31% over the same period. It has added only 154 bitcoins since listing, its mNAV is just 0.55x, and CEO Jack Mallers has also stepped down. Newly listed XRP treasury company Evernorth has fallen 57% in just over a month, with an mNAV of 1.29x.

The sole exception is Hyperliquid Strategies, which is up 104% since listing, largely in line with HYPE’s 100% gain. However, it has also retreated 44% from its September high, and its mNAV is 0.91x.

Protos’s conclusion is straightforward: companies that merely hoard coins have no way to differentiate themselves from ETFs, while those using financial engineering introduce new risks. Only two of the five companies still have market caps above the value of their holdings, putting the treasury model under scrutiny. Are treasury stocks trading below net asset value a buying opportunity or a value trap? What do you think?

$BTC $TRX $XRP

#币安广场 #比特币 #CryptoTreasuries

(Source: Protos)

⚠️Risk disclaimer: The above is for sharing market information only and does not constitute investment advice. Investing involves risk; please exercise caution.