Two MIT brothers took $25 million in 12 seconds, yet were acquitted. What exactly did the court reject?

A Manhattan federal court issued its ruling on Monday. The two brothers, Anton and James, were found not guilty on all three charges they faced: wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud, and conspiracy to commit money laundering. Last November, the case ended in a mistrial after the jury failed to reach a unanimous verdict.

This was the first time the U.S. government had brought criminal charges over this kind of MEV activity. MEV is the extraction of value through methods such as transaction ordering.

The incident took place in April 2023.

The brothers used bait transactions to lure bots that carried out sandwich attacks. When it was their validator’s turn to propose a block, they exploited a relay validation flaw to access the block contents early, kept the bots’ buy orders, and replaced them with their own transactions. In about 12 seconds, the bots lost roughly $25 million.

A sandwich attack means buying ahead of a target transaction, then selling after that transaction pushes up the price.

CoinDesk’s review of the court opinion notes that about $3 million in proceeds was frozen, while the rest had already been transferred. The victims were bots engaged in sandwich trading—not ordinary users who were directly sandwiched.

But here’s the point that’s easiest to get wrong.

An acquittal does not mean the court ruled that this kind of conduct is acceptable.

The judge was not considering whether the conduct was ethical, but whether prosecutors had proved that the defendants made a false representation on which someone else relied. The wire fraud charges in this case did not meet that threshold.

The phrase “no terms of service” in the coverage stands out, but it cannot be boiled down to “no terms means you can take money however you like.”

What we can say is that these three charges did not hold up. What we cannot conclude is that exploiting vulnerabilities for profit is legal in every circumstance—much less that this case is a how-to guide.

What blockchain code allows to happen and what criminal law can prove are two different things. This ruling drew the boundary for specific criminal charges; it did not resolve every question about the rules governing the industry.

What do you think?
A On-chain adversarial behavior should be a risk borne by participants
B Exploiting a relay vulnerability cannot be considered ordinary trading
C A failed conviction does not mean the industry’s rules are clear

#MEV #ETH #以太坊