U.S. judge delivers final ruling: $25 million taken in 12 seconds—and it’s not fraud
Manhattan federal judge Jessica G. L. Clarke ruled Monday that MIT brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno are not guilty. All three charges were dismissed, and there will be no retrial.
In April 2023, the two exploited a vulnerability in the relay code of MEV-Boost (open-source software that helps validators order transactions), taking $25 million from Ethereum trading bots in about 12 seconds. They were arrested in May 2024, and their first trial ended in a hung jury last November.
The judge’s reasoning was straightforward: prosecutors could not produce a “material misrepresentation,” Ethereum is not a regulated market, and the bait transaction was on-chain within a minute.
At the time of publication, ETH is trading at $1,789.68.
This case essentially draws a line around “code is the rules of the game”—exploiting a code vulnerability is not the same as lying to deceive. The judge also cited a 2025 precedent from the Mango Markets case, in which a withdrawal of more than $100 million was also found not guilty.
I’ll be watching to see whether prosecutors appeal and whether other cases cite this precedent. If an appeals court overturns the ruling, this line will have to be redrawn.
Do you think this is “technical innocence” or “the law failing to keep up”?
$BTC $ETH $SOL
#以太坊 #MEV
Manhattan federal judge Jessica G. L. Clarke ruled Monday that MIT brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno are not guilty. All three charges were dismissed, and there will be no retrial.
In April 2023, the two exploited a vulnerability in the relay code of MEV-Boost (open-source software that helps validators order transactions), taking $25 million from Ethereum trading bots in about 12 seconds. They were arrested in May 2024, and their first trial ended in a hung jury last November.
The judge’s reasoning was straightforward: prosecutors could not produce a “material misrepresentation,” Ethereum is not a regulated market, and the bait transaction was on-chain within a minute.
At the time of publication, ETH is trading at $1,789.68.
This case essentially draws a line around “code is the rules of the game”—exploiting a code vulnerability is not the same as lying to deceive. The judge also cited a 2025 precedent from the Mango Markets case, in which a withdrawal of more than $100 million was also found not guilty.
I’ll be watching to see whether prosecutors appeal and whether other cases cite this precedent. If an appeals court overturns the ruling, this line will have to be redrawn.
Do you think this is “technical innocence” or “the law failing to keep up”?
$BTC $ETH $SOL
#以太坊 #MEV
