Suppose there’s someone called Xiaoqi. At the close on August 19, $CHZ closed at 0.01275. He set himself a rule: look only at that day’s fully closed daily candlestick. The upper wick is the high minus whichever is higher, the open or the close; the body is the absolute difference between the open and the close. The upper wick must be at least twice the body and at least half of the day’s high-to-low range (50%, inclusive). If the body is exactly 0, he only requires the upper wick to be at least half the range. If the conditions are met, he buys at the close and sells at the next day’s close. If the conditions still hold on the day he sells, he sells and buys back. He does not add to his position while holding. His colleague Xiao Cang converted all 1000 USDT into the coin at 0.01275 on the same day and planned to hold until the end. The replay below excludes trading fees.
Over these 90 days, there were 8 days that met the rule. Xiaoqi bought 8 times and sold 8 times, including one sell-and-buy-back. He ended with cash. None of the 8 days had a body exactly equal to 0.
The first 3 fully closed daily candlesticks didn’t give him a signal. On August 22, the upper wick was long enough, so he bought at 0.01434. He sold the next day for a 3.28% gain, bringing his balance to 1032.78. He bought again on August 31 at 0.01326, then sold the next day for +1.13%, bringing his balance to 1044.46.
His most profitable trade came on September 12. He bought at 0.01433 and sold on September 13 for +3.63%, bringing his balance to 1082.36.
Then he sat out for 16 fully closed daily candlesticks. On September 22, CHZ closed at the highest closing price of these 90 days, 0.01714, up 34.43% from the starting price. Xiao Cang’s balance was 1344.31; Xiaoqi was still at 1082.36 and missed that candle.
On September 30, he bought at 0.01626 and sold the next day at a 0.55% loss, bringing his balance to 1076.37. This was the only losing trade among his 8 sales.
On October 3, the price touched the 90-day high of 0.01805 intraday, but the candle closed with a sufficiently long upper wick, at 0.01701. Xiaoqi bought at that closing price and sold the next day for just a 0.06% gain, bringing his balance to 1077.00. October 4 still met the conditions on the day he sold, so he sold and bought back at the same price, 0.01702. The next day’s close was still 0.01702, so this trade broke even and his balance remained 1077.00.
He bought at 0.01547 on October 10, then sold the next day for +2.13%, bringing his balance to 1099.98. His final trade was on October 26: he bought at 0.01287 and sold the next day for +1.40%, ending at 1115.36.
Results over these 90 days (drawdown calculated using daily closes):
Xiao Cang, fully invested the whole time: 765.49 USDT, -23.45%, with a maximum drawdown of 43.58% (from the September 22 closing high of 0.01714 and a balance of 1344.31 to the November 14 close of 0.00967 and a balance of 758.43). On November 16, it closed at 0.00976, 43.06% below the closing high; it would need to rise another 75.61% to return to that high. Over the same period, $BTC fell -6.42% from its August 19 close to its November 16 close. By the November 14 close—the lowest close—Xiaoqi was already out of the market, and his balance remained at 1115.36.
Xiaoqi, holding overnight only on days when the upper wick was at least twice the body and at least half the day’s range: 1115.36 USDT, +11.54%, with a maximum drawdown of 0.55% (from a balance of 1082.36 on September 13 to 1076.37 after selling on October 1). Of his 8 sales, 6 were profitable, 1 was a loss, and 1 broke even.
The above is a replay of a rule using Binance spot CHZUSDT and BTCUSDT historical daily data (UTC daily candles, closed data from 2026-08-19 to 11-16); it does not indicate what will happen in the future. Over these 90 days, he missed the highest close on September 22, but bought overnight at the close on October 3, the day the high was reached. Would you use the ratio of the upper wick to the body to decide whether to hold overnight?
Over these 90 days, there were 8 days that met the rule. Xiaoqi bought 8 times and sold 8 times, including one sell-and-buy-back. He ended with cash. None of the 8 days had a body exactly equal to 0.
The first 3 fully closed daily candlesticks didn’t give him a signal. On August 22, the upper wick was long enough, so he bought at 0.01434. He sold the next day for a 3.28% gain, bringing his balance to 1032.78. He bought again on August 31 at 0.01326, then sold the next day for +1.13%, bringing his balance to 1044.46.
His most profitable trade came on September 12. He bought at 0.01433 and sold on September 13 for +3.63%, bringing his balance to 1082.36.
Then he sat out for 16 fully closed daily candlesticks. On September 22, CHZ closed at the highest closing price of these 90 days, 0.01714, up 34.43% from the starting price. Xiao Cang’s balance was 1344.31; Xiaoqi was still at 1082.36 and missed that candle.
On September 30, he bought at 0.01626 and sold the next day at a 0.55% loss, bringing his balance to 1076.37. This was the only losing trade among his 8 sales.
On October 3, the price touched the 90-day high of 0.01805 intraday, but the candle closed with a sufficiently long upper wick, at 0.01701. Xiaoqi bought at that closing price and sold the next day for just a 0.06% gain, bringing his balance to 1077.00. October 4 still met the conditions on the day he sold, so he sold and bought back at the same price, 0.01702. The next day’s close was still 0.01702, so this trade broke even and his balance remained 1077.00.
He bought at 0.01547 on October 10, then sold the next day for +2.13%, bringing his balance to 1099.98. His final trade was on October 26: he bought at 0.01287 and sold the next day for +1.40%, ending at 1115.36.
Results over these 90 days (drawdown calculated using daily closes):
Xiao Cang, fully invested the whole time: 765.49 USDT, -23.45%, with a maximum drawdown of 43.58% (from the September 22 closing high of 0.01714 and a balance of 1344.31 to the November 14 close of 0.00967 and a balance of 758.43). On November 16, it closed at 0.00976, 43.06% below the closing high; it would need to rise another 75.61% to return to that high. Over the same period, $BTC fell -6.42% from its August 19 close to its November 16 close. By the November 14 close—the lowest close—Xiaoqi was already out of the market, and his balance remained at 1115.36.
Xiaoqi, holding overnight only on days when the upper wick was at least twice the body and at least half the day’s range: 1115.36 USDT, +11.54%, with a maximum drawdown of 0.55% (from a balance of 1082.36 on September 13 to 1076.37 after selling on October 1). Of his 8 sales, 6 were profitable, 1 was a loss, and 1 broke even.
The above is a replay of a rule using Binance spot CHZUSDT and BTCUSDT historical daily data (UTC daily candles, closed data from 2026-08-19 to 11-16); it does not indicate what will happen in the future. Over these 90 days, he missed the highest close on September 22, but bought overnight at the close on October 3, the day the high was reached. Would you use the ratio of the upper wick to the body to decide whether to hold overnight?