The three storage giants were collectively hammered on Monday. The trigger wasn’t export controls, but a lawsuit.

On November 14, the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California denied motions to dismiss filed by Samsung Electronics, SK hynix, and Micron Technology, sending the DRAM antitrust class action into discovery and toward a trial on the merits. A motion to dismiss is a request by defendants for the court to throw out a case outright. The court’s refusal means it found the plaintiffs’ allegations worth pursuing.

The plaintiffs are 14 consumers from five U.S. states and three small and midsize computer makers. They filed suit in June this year, accusing the three companies of conspiring to restrict supplies of commodity DRAM starting in 2022 and drive prices up 697% over 18 months. Commodity DRAM is the memory chip used in computers and servers. The three companies together account for 91.5% of global DRAM sales, and the plaintiffs are seeking damages equal to three times their actual losses. The defendants must file their answers by December 7, and the first case management conference is scheduled for January 12, 2027. In its annual report filed in October, Micron had already listed this lawsuit as an antitrust legal risk.

The market voted with its feet on Monday: Micron fell 7.62% to $719.02, with a single bearish candle breaking through its 200-day moving average of $765.71 (the average closing price over the past 200 trading days, and a key dividing line between long-term bulls and bears). It closed about 6.1% below the average, down nearly 35% from its interim peak of around $1,100 in October. It continued to probe lower before the market opened, down about 0.8% to $713.15; SK hynix’s U.S. depositary receipts fell 7.29% to $122.18, a 52-week low, while shares in South Korea fell 7.89% to 1.12 million won and dropped another roughly 2% today to 1.098 million won; SanDisk fell more than 8%; and the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index lost 5.28% to 9,610.65, with all 30 of its components in the red. New U.S. Commerce Department rules tightening export controls on AI chips are also still reverberating. With both developments piling up, semiconductors were Monday’s worst-performing sector.

Ironically, the fundamentals haven’t weakened at all: SK hynix posted third-quarter revenue of 104.6 trillion won, up 328% year over year; Micron reported quarterly revenue of $54.2 billion and earnings per share of $33.42, while the market expects next-quarter revenue of about $63.8 billion and earnings per share of $39.37; and SK hynix announced plans to invest 1.4 trillion won over the next five years to expand its domestic supply chain in South Korea. The pricing story hasn’t changed, and orders haven’t dried up.

That’s the most painful part of this sell-off: the more prices rise, the larger the base for damages claimed in the lawsuit. The 697% figure is a badge of honor for profits on an earnings call, but evidence for the plaintiffs in court. What the market fears now isn’t a collapse in demand, but not knowing how much the companies may ultimately have to pay or how long the case will drag on. Uncertainty itself is the biggest headwind.

Keep an eye on two things: first, the defendants’ answers due December 7. Whether their language is combative or signals a desire to settle will set the tone. Second, Nvidia’s earnings tonight, and whether the storage stocks can catch their breath on the AI demand story. Until the lawsuit is resolved, treat any rebound as an oversold bounce, not a reversal.
#美股 #MemoryChips
$MU $NVDA $QQQ