ENS DAO is voting on a proposal that almost nobody is talking about, but for ENS holders it matters more than most good or bad news: from now on, you basically won’t get to vote on how the treasury is invested.

Proposal [7.5] IPS Amendment No. 2 is up for a Snapshot vote from 11/16 18:30 to 11/21 18:30 (UTC). The gist is simple: the Investment Policy Statement (IPS) can be amended with approval from 4 of the 5 ENS Foundation board members, after 7 days of public notice on the forum, with disclosure within 14 days of the change. Asset allocation, strategy, fee terms with the asset manager, and whether to replace the asset manager will all be up to the board. The DAO will retain control only over the minimum operating reserve, this amendment rule itself, and the ability to submit a Social proposal to overturn it.

To be fair, the real transfer of power happened with the “Next Era” proposal on August 11. It was executed onchain, and the treasury Safe has long been under the Foundation’s timelock. This amendment is just paperwork. Having to run a Snapshot vote for every portfolio adjustment really is stupid.

But there are a few things worth keeping an eye on.

How much money is involved? The asset manager kpk’s own monthly report says the treasury had $90.71 million in AUM at the end of October, 45.5% of it in ETH. ENS’s market cap is currently around $167 million (CoinGecko, around 11:45 UTC+8). A pool worth nearly half the market cap is shifting from token-holder votes to the hands of five people. ENS itself doesn’t distribute treasury funds, so governance rights are one of the few “benefits” it offers—and this makes them weaker still.

Who’s backing it? The first person to explicitly support it on the forum was kpk—the very party that will negotiate fees and terms with the board going forward, without needing the DAO’s approval. In October, it moved about $6.6 million from Aave, Compound, and other platforms into a set of higher-yield products, including its own KPK USDC Yield V2 vault, where the treasury has $8.85 million. The yield went from about 4.5% to about 6%. The move itself may be perfectly reasonable, but “using your own product while helping set the rules that govern you” is a structure that deserves scrutiny. I couldn’t find the fees this vault charges the treasury specified in the monthly report.

What’s on paper and what happens onchain aren’t the same thing, either. The 4/5 threshold is in the board charter; onchain execution relies on a 3/5 multisig and a 9-day timelock, during which the security council can cancel it. That’s the Foundation’s own explanation on the forum. In plain English, 4/5 depends on self-restraint; the contracts only require 3/5.

Voting status: As of around 11:45 UTC+8, 12 addresses had voted, with about 180,000 ENS all in favor and none opposed. The Social proposal has no quorum requirement. At the same time, Amendment No. 1 is also up for a vote. It would allow the treasury to sell covered calls and cash-secured puts, with the board likewise making the final call on execution.

I don’t think this is a rug pull; the Foundation has left the DAO a way to overturn it. But in a DAO where 12 addresses vote, “you can overturn it” is pretty much the same as nothing. If you’re betting on ENS for its governance value, it’s time to recalculate how much that’s worth.

#ENS