On November 14, U.S. time, Bitcoin briefly fell to around $62,000, its lowest level in three months, and was down 17% for the week.

The most widely circulated claim online in recent days is that Binance was hacked last month and had $6.3 billion stolen, and is now secretly selling Bitcoin to plug the hole. Some have put it more bluntly: Binance is deliberately crashing the market to liquidate users, then pocketing the liquidation proceeds.

But on November 15, Binance founder Changpeng Zhao (CZ) responded on X: “Binance did not sell crypto,” adding that he had bought some over the past few days.

Did Binance actually sell?

CoinGlass calculated the difference between "aggressive buying" and "aggressive selling" in the spot markets of various exchanges. From October 31 to November 15, the heaviest selling pressure was on Coinbase, a U.S.-listed exchange, with a net sell of $1.08 billion, about NT$35.6 billion.

What about Binance? It was actually a net buy, of about $51.88 million.

◆◆◆

But note that this number is based on all the people who placed orders on Binance, not Binance's own buying and selling, so it cannot prove that Binance did not sell any at all.

However, it at least shows that over these two weeks, people placing orders on Binance were buying more than selling, and the area with the most concentrated selling pressure was not Binance. As for "deliberately making users liquidate," there is currently no report or on-chain data to support that.

Still, conspiracy theories don't just come out of nowhere.

Binance's proof of reserves released on November 12 showed that the Bitcoin users held on Binance were fully backed. But after Binance was hacked, it used $6.34 billion of company funds to cover users, and it has not disclosed how much of that money was Bitcoin or how much was spent.

So who was actually selling this time?

◆◆◆

On-chain data analyst James Check believes that the people selling Bitcoin were mostly those who only chased in when Bitcoin broke above $80,000 in September, and who now cannot tolerate the paper losses and can only cut their losses and exit.

As of November 13, U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs had also seen net outflows for seven consecutive trading days, totaling about $1.91 billion, or about NT$62.9 billion.

Looking at these figures together, I think this time it seems less like one exchange was orchestrating things behind the scenes, and more like many people were selling at once: some cut their losses, some pulled money from ETFs, and some sold coins to wait for the listing of new AI stocks.

The next time you see "some big whale is dumping," you can first ask three things:

  • Is there a wallet address or data source attached?

  • On platforms like CoinGlass, is there corresponding selling pressure that can be found?

  • Did the person involved respond?

As of the morning of November 16, Bitcoin was quoted at about $65,250 on CoinGecko, or about NT$2.15 million.

In this downturn, which version did you hear? Did you panic too?

Feel free to share with me~

⚠️ The above content is for reference only and does not constitute any investment advice.