Suppose there’s a guy named Azhe who works at a small company handling foreign-trade documents. His boss has a habit of splitting his pay into three installments each month: one on the 1st, one on the 11th, and one on the 21st. Azhe follows that schedule, buying 100 USDT worth of $ZRX at the UTC closing price each payday—no chart-watching, no extra purchases.

I ran the numbers for him using Binance spot ZRX/USDT daily candles that had closed. From the first purchase on August 21 to the last on November 11, that’s 9 purchases totaling 900 USDT. I calculated the results through the November 15 close (UTC). The November 16 candle hadn’t closed yet, so I left it out.

The first three purchases barely made a difference: the August 21 close was 0.0955, September 1 was 0.0957, and September 11 was 0.1006. After the third purchase, his balance was worth 310.46, up just 3.49%. Then the price started rising. His September 21 purchase was at 0.1192, bringing his balance to 467.86, up 16.97%.

Of the 9 purchase dates, October 11 looked best on paper. That day he bought his sixth installment at 0.1291. He had invested 600, and his balance was worth 712.54, up 18.76%. What he didn’t know was that the previous day, October 10, had already marked the 90-day high: an intraday peak of 0.134 and a closing price of 0.1312.

The next three purchases got cheaper and cheaper: 0.1128 on October 21, 0.0976 on November 1, and 0.0872 on November 11. After the ninth purchase, his balance was worth 747.93, down 16.90%. At the November 15 close of 0.0812, the 8,577.18 ZRX he’d bought with 900 USDT were worth 696.47, a loss of 22.61%. His average cost was about 0.1049.

Here’s the twist: his colleague Xiaozhou invested the entire 900 in one go on August 21. By November 15, it was worth 765.24, down 14.97%—so he actually lost less than Azhe. That’s because several of Azhe’s purchases landed right in the high-price stretch from late September to mid-October.

Azhe later wondered what would have happened if he’d stopped after his best-performing purchase on October 11. It turns out that his first 6 purchases, totaling 600 USDT, would have been worth 448.17 on November 15, down 25.31%—a little worse than after all 9 purchases. Those last three bargain buys had pulled his average cost down somewhat.

Over the same period, $BTC was down 16.58% from the August 21 close to the November 15 close. These figures are all based on historical candles that had closed. Change the starting date or the coin, and the results could be completely different. This is not investment advice.

If it were you, would you have stopped on the day your balance was up 18.76%, or kept buying on your usual payday schedule?