The share of Bitcoin’s active supply in profit has fallen below 45%. The first thing I want to look at is the denominator behind that 45%.

On November 14, analyst Darkfost published an estimate that excluded coins that hadn’t moved for more than ten years, on the grounds that a large portion of them lack liquidity. Of the remaining supply, less than 45% was in profit. He also noted that readings below 40% have historically often coincided with market bottoms during pullbacks. That’s a historical relationship based on a specific sample; it can’t be directly translated into “more than half of investors have already sold at a loss.”

Supply, number of holders, and trading volume are three different measures. A single holder may have multiple positions with different cost bases; unrealized losses don’t mean those positions have been sold. So this chart shows the pressure on the coins in the sample, but it doesn’t tell us how much selling has yet to happen. Readings based on all supply, or on a different age range for the coins, also can’t be directly compared.

Bulls focus on the possibility that, as fewer coins remain in profit, fewer holders may be willing to sell at low prices, making panic phases more likely to give rise to a rebound. Bears worry that holders of coins at a loss may still be forced to sell because of margin calls, redemptions, or cash needs. Falling into a historically observed range doesn’t automatically bring in buyers.

I’m inclined to be cautious: 45% can be a signal to look more closely, but it isn’t enough evidence on its own to buy the dip. There’s another feedback loop that’s easy to overlook: a rise in the price of $BTC can itself bring some coins back into profit, so an improving indicator and a price rebound aren’t necessarily two independent bullish reasons.

I’d rather keep watching to see whether selling pressure eases on pullbacks, whether spot trading volume can absorb the selling, and whether the price can hold after the share in profit improves. Would you start building a long position in $BTC around 45%, or wait for buying pressure to prove itself before accepting a higher entry price?
#BitcoinActiveSupplyInProfitFallsBelow45%