COHR Plunges 6% Friday: Earnings Beat Expectations, $20 Billion Order in Hand, Yet the Stock Has Been Cut in Half

COHR closed Friday at $218.15, down 6.00%. It hit an intraday low of $207.69, then fell another 2.5% after hours to $212.68. But don’t focus on just one day: COHR actually gained 28.5% for the week—first surging, then plunging. That volatility is par for the course with this stock.

The results were actually strong. In its fiscal Q1 2027 report released on November 4, revenue hit a record $2.37 billion, up 56% year over year on a pro forma basis. Non-GAAP EPS was $2.09, up 80% year over year. Both revenue and earnings beat expectations. Data center and communications revenue was $1.95 billion, up 79% year over year and accounting for 82% of total revenue. Non-GAAP gross margin was 40.6%, up 184 basis points year over year.

The bigger card is the order book: the company signed a five-year, approximately $20 billion PhotonLink long-term agreement with a major AI customer, with revenue set to ramp up in early 2028. PhotonLink revenue is expected to exceed $100 million in the March quarter next year and $250 million per quarter before the end of 2027. Management raised its fiscal 2027 full-year revenue growth guidance to above 60%, targeting its first $3 billion quarter by fiscal year-end and its first $4 billion quarter in fiscal 2028. Guidance for next quarter is revenue of $2.55–$2.75 billion and EPS of $2.28–$2.48.

But the market isn’t buying it: the stock has been cut in half (-50.4%) from its 52-week high of $440 on June 3, and has fallen below its 50-day moving average of $265.27 and 200-day moving average of $296.81. It’s down 12.95% over one month and 42.96% over six months.

The logic isn’t hard to understand: earnings reflect “what’s already happened,” while valuation is anchored to “discounted future expectations.” Optical communications has been one of the strongest-performing sectors in this AI rally, and COHR is still up 56.6% over the past year. A beta of 2.22 means it surges quickly on the way up and falls hard on the way down. Friday wasn’t an isolated problem at the company; the entire AI optics sector pulled back together. Peer LITE also fell 4.49% to $596.62, down 31.39% over one month and 47.8% from its $1,143 high.

There are positive signs, too: on November 9, the CEO bought about $997,000 worth of shares with his own money, followed by a director buying about $223,000 worth. The median analyst price target is $380 (26 analysts), implying 74% upside from the current price. But price targets are forward-looking; they don’t mean the stock will stop falling in the short term.

My take: fundamentals and share price are temporarily out of sync. In the short term, watch whether Friday’s low of $207.69 holds; if it doesn’t, the next level to watch is the $200 round-number mark. In the medium term, two things need to materialize: a ramp-up in PhotonLink revenue and stabilization in the sector. Don’t rush to buy the dip—wait for trading volume and moving averages to stabilize.

Risk warning: High-beta stocks are extremely volatile. Even after an earnings beat, the stock fell more than 10% the next day. Revenue from the $20 billion order won’t ramp up until 2028, so it won’t solve near-term problems. If expectations for AI capital spending continue to cool, the optics sector could face another round of valuation compression.

Personal research; not investment advice.

$COHR $LITE
#Coherent #光通信 #AI infrastructure