6.6% didn’t arrive; 6.5% did.

The two drafts last night stated the forecast: October PPI at 6.6% year over year and +0.4% month over month. Tonight’s figures came in at 6.5% year over year and +0.3% month over month, both below expectations. But officials also said the annual increase was the largest since November 2022. Below expectations doesn’t mean a reversal; first, be clear about which figure came in low.

The core figure needs another layer of breakdown. One report says that “excluding food, energy, and trade services,” it was +0.5% month over month and +4.9% over 12 months; others say that “excluding food and energy,” it was +0.3% month over month and 5.0% year over year, with the previous figure also revised from 0.7% to 0.8%. Different exclusions mean different denominators, so you can’t subtract them—and don’t rush to say core inflation cooled too.

For the same data, there are at least four sets of rate-hike odds: 89.7%, 93.4%, and 88.5%, while another figure of 84.7% was recorded before the release; one source also directly says that “25 basis points are fully priced in.” The times and sources differ, so don’t add them up or present them as odds that kept rising. The day’s rally in equity futures and gold and silver, alongside one report saying the 10-year Treasury yield fell and another saying it rose to 5.125%, reflects events occurring around the same time, not cause and effect.

For BTC, Saturday’s readings also differ: weak trading around 68.5K, a headline saying it fell below 67,000, and the 11-13 figures of 69,376 and 69,050. The timestamps differ, so none should be presented as the current price. ETF outflows—-1.854 billion on 11-14, -10.7 billion over one week, -23.5 billion over two weeks, and about -23.5 billion for IBIT over 11 consecutive trading days—have different starting dates and sources, so they can’t be added together either.

Don’t confuse the two updates: Binance said today that a zero-knowledge proof has been generated, allowing users to independently verify 1:1 reserves; it also said that 87 network withdrawals were restored this week, with the rest targeted for restoration by the end of next week. Verifiability doesn’t mean funds have been recovered, nor that all withdrawals are back online.

Still ahead: Nvidia’s earnings on 11-17, the minutes on 11-18, PCE on 11-25, the rate decision on 12-09, and the CPI report resuming year-over-year comparisons on 12-10. One data point is in; the answers are still to come.