The Fear & Greed Index is at 13 today, signaling extreme fear and its lowest reading since July 1, when it was 11. Bitcoin isn't showing any mercy: Binance prices plunged to 66,456 intraday, setting a new low since August 19; as I write this, it's hovering around 67,200. That's a drop of about 23% from September's peak of 87,396. A level many had treated as a floor has also been breached: the 200-week moving average, at around 68,000.
Last night, there should have been a “slightly better” number. U.S. October PPI rose 0.3% month over month, versus expectations of 0.4%; but year over year, it was up 6.5%—the biggest increase since November 2022. The slightly lower-than-expected monthly reading did nothing to support prices. Add another data point: by the 13th, U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs had recorded net outflows for seven consecutive trading days, totaling about 1.91 billion, and about 2.35 billion since the start of November. In interest rate futures, the probability of a 25-basis-point rate hike in December remains near 90%.
So today’s market action is easy to spin into a story: the moving average has broken, fund shares are being redeemed, the annual inflation rate is at a four-year high, and the thermometer has hit 13. In the history books, this moving average has been called both a floor and a trap. Either story can be made to add up—it depends on whether you want to scare yourself or reassure yourself.
Morgan Housel has a line in *The Psychology of Money* that 3,150 people on WeChat Reading have highlighted:
“The problem is that no matter how diligently we study or how open-minded we are, we can’t truly replicate the power of fear and uncertainty.”
This line feels as if it were written specifically for today. The 200-week moving average is arithmetic, the fear index is a thermometer, and the PPI is a table of figures. You can learn about all of them, and explain them in full. But what really matters isn’t whether you can recall the year the moving average acted as a floor; it’s that ineffable force you feel when the number 13 hits the market. Reading can make you think you’ve already rehearsed a moment like this—until prices hammer out 66,456, and you realize that rehearsal and the real thing aren’t the same.
I’m still bullish on Bitcoin’s long-term direction; one moving average can’t change that. But being bullish doesn’t mean reading 13 as “the worst is behind us,” let alone seeing that the moving average once acted as a floor in the past and writing today’s fear a happy ending in advance. A thermometer can tell you it’s cold; it can’t make the decision for you. History is worth reading—but having read it doesn’t mean you’ve lived through it.