887,000 shares → 7.01 million shares; $45.3 million → $509 million: Jane Street, Wall Street’s biggest market maker, nearly octupled its holdings in Fidelity’s Bitcoin ETF in the third quarter.

#JaneStreet富达比特币ETF持仓增至近8倍 Today’s third most popular topic on the plaza is about Jane Street’s 13F holdings report, filed with the U.S. SEC on November 12. It reflects holdings as of September 30 and was only picked up by the media last night.

First, who is Jane Street? It’s one of the world’s largest market makers, making money by quoting buy and sell prices—in trader parlance, “the house” that “just earns the spread and doesn’t bet on direction.” In the second quarter, it was still the largest institutional holder of BlackRock’s IBIT, increasing its holdings by 324% in a single quarter.

In the third quarter, it switched things up: it cut its IBIT holdings by 19%, from 24.88 million shares to 20.22 million. But because Bitcoin’s price rose, the value of that position actually increased from $828 million to $957 million. It increased its Fidelity FBTC holdings from 887,000 shares to 7.01 million, with their value rising from $45.3 million to $509 million. It also bought around 9 million shares of ARKB, worth about $249 million. Its Ethereum ETF holdings more than doubled, increasing by 7.83 million shares, worth about $158 million. Its three Bitcoin ETF holdings totaled around $1.79 billion, compared with about $926 million at the end of June—nearly doubling on paper in a single quarter. JPMorgan also added to its IBIT holdings in the same quarter, increasing them by about 1 million shares to 11.41 million.

Here’s the interesting part: the report reflects holdings as of September 30, when Bitcoin hadn’t yet fallen below $70,000. Today, Bitcoin is hovering around $69,000, the Fear Index is at 20, ETFs have seen $1.56 billion in net outflows year to date, and outflows have continued for six straight days. Retail investors are cutting their losses, while market makers were adding to their positions in the third quarter.

Let me be clear about my view: don’t take this as a signal to buy the dip. First, the 13F only shows holdings as of September 30. Nobody knows whether Jane Street has exited since October, or how much it may have sold. Second, Jane Street is a market maker, and much of its ETF holdings are inventory used to hedge $BTC options and derivatives. That doesn’t mean it’s bullish on Bitcoin. What’s really worth noting isn’t “how much it bought,” but “that it hasn’t left”—it rebalanced without exiting; the basket changed, but the money stayed in the market. That’s a world apart from retail investors shouting “crash” after a few days of ETF outflows. We’ll have to wait for the next 13F to get a directional signal; we won’t see it until at least February next year. Until then, this report proves just one thing: at the end of September, the big money hadn’t panicked yet.

The 13F only shows holdings as of September 30—what do you think Jane Street did during this latest October sell-off: keep adding to its positions, or quietly get out?

—Bao Bao