MSCI has officially confirmed that, after the market close on November 30, Strategy (formerly MicroStrategy) will be removed from global equity indexes, including the MSCI USA Index. Japan’s Metaplanet will also be dropped from the MSCI Japan Small Cap Index. The reason is clear: under the new rules introduced on October 15, these companies look more like “non-operating companies”—closer to investment funds—and therefore don’t belong in equity indexes.
After the news broke, Strategy shares fell in after-hours trading. Bitcoin, however, didn’t make a big move. Its current price on Binance is around $73,448, about 8.6% lower than a week ago, and it traded between $73,260 and $74,217 today. Add another data point: through the 11th, U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs had recorded net outflows for five consecutive trading days, totaling about $1.44 billion, including roughly $300 million on the 11th. The Fear & Greed Index stood at 28, still in the fear zone. U.S. stocks closed higher on Wednesday, with the Nasdaq rebounding sharply, but Bitcoin didn’t follow suit.
First, separate two things that are easy to conflate. Being kicked out of Strategy does not mean the company is being forced to sell the coins it holds. According to public reports, the company still holds 850364 bitcoins, worth roughly $62.5 billion. Funds that track the relevant indexes hold about 13 million shares, by the company’s own estimate—less than a day’s normal trading volume, and worth about $1.6 billion at Wednesday’s price. That creates selling pressure on the stock; it is not an order to sell bitcoin. What may really change is the “issue shares, buy bitcoin” machine: the premium of the share price to the net value of its holdings has fallen from around 3.4 times at its peak to around 1.08 times. Issuing new shares to accumulate more bitcoin will become increasingly uneconomical.
It’s easy to weld all this into one sentence: institutions have abandoned bitcoin.
There’s a passage in Howard Marks’s The Most Important Thing that 4,144 people have highlighted on WeRead:
“First-level thinking says, ‘It’s a good company; let’s buy the stock.’ Second-level thinking says, ‘It’s a good company, but everyone thinks it’s a good company, so it isn’t. The stock is overvalued and overpriced; let’s sell.’”
Today, it’s useful to turn that thinking around. First-level thinking says: The index has dropped crypto treasury companies, the institutional narrative is broken, and bitcoin should plunge along with them. Second-level thinking looks at another layer: MSCI is making a decision about company classification, not weighing bitcoin; passive selling of the stock does not mean the coins must be dumped right now; the flywheel of issuing shares to buy bitcoin may slow down, but what’s slowing is the financing efficiency of the wrapper, not bitcoin being declared invalid. Reading the delisting of the wrapper as the asset being thrown away is like treating a simple question as if it were the original one.
I remain bullish on bitcoin’s long-term direction. But being bullish doesn’t mean treating Strategy’s ticker as bitcoin itself, let alone seeing an index delisting and writing it up as the final chapter of institutional retreat. The actual rebalancing won’t happen until November 30. An index can drop a company; it can’t weigh bitcoin. Rather than getting angry at the stamp on the wrapper, it’s better to see clearly what has been removed—and what remains.