$2.8 billion in passive selling could hit Saylor after the November 30 close—but let’s be clear: that $2.8 billion is selling stocks, not Bitcoin.

#Strategy could be dropped from MSCI, facing up to $2.8 billion in selling pressure

On October 15, MSCI approved a new rule: companies that make money from holding assets rather than operating an actual business will no longer be eligible for its global investable market indexes. The rule takes effect after the close on November 30. Strategy is on the potential removal list—when MSCI ran a simulation using May financial reports, it had already removed Strategy and Japan’s Metaplanet. The final list will be announced tomorrow after 6 a.m. Beijing time.

The $2.8 billion figure comes from JPMorgan’s estimate: index funds tracking MSCI must sell their holdings by the November 30 close if a constituent is removed. The resulting selling could total between $1.57 billion and $2.8 billion. $MSTR closed at $121.07 yesterday, down 3.6%, and is about 6.4% below its November 5 price of $129.30.

But there are two numbers to keep in perspective. First, Strategy’s own estimate is that funds tracking MSCI global indexes hold only about 13 million MSTR shares, or 3.1% of the total shares outstanding—roughly 60% of its 30-day average daily trading volume. Less than a day’s trading could absorb that. Second, the index rule forces funds to sell the stock, not Strategy to sell its coins: not one of the 850,364 bitcoins it holds will be sold because of this rule. At today’s price of $73,781, that amounts to about $1.4 billion in unrealized losses—but those are unrealized losses, not forced sales.

So what this really hurts isn’t Bitcoin’s price, but the “public companies issue shares to buy crypto” playbook. If MSTR is dropped from the index, the door narrows for treasury companies hoping to rely on passive index-fund money to buy their shares. Saylor raised $283.8 million last week, but two-thirds of it didn’t go toward buying Bitcoin—it went to repurchasing preferred stock. Financing priorities are already shifting, and this MSCI move is another nudge in that direction.

My take: $2.8 billion in selling sounds scary, but it’s a one-off, mechanical event, and the market has been pricing it in since the new rule came out on October 15. MSTR has already fallen quite a bit over the past month. The real thing to watch is tomorrow morning’s list: if Strategy is on it, there could be another wave of passive rebalancing pressure before November 30; if it’s not, that removes the overhang. Either way, Bitcoin itself isn’t on the hook for this $2.8 billion—if you hold BTC, don’t mistake stock selling for Bitcoin selling.

I’d reconsider my view based on two things: whether Strategy is on tomorrow’s list, and whether MSTR can reclaim $130 on strong volume after the November 30 rebalancing.

I’ll break down the list as soon as it comes out tomorrow morning, and I’ll follow the November 30 rebalancing too—follow me, and you won’t have to keep refreshing MSCI’s announcements yourself.

Do you hold MSTR, or an index fund that includes MSTR? With MSCI putting the brakes on this strategy for treasury companies, how much farther do you think it can go?

—Baobao