Author: Nancy, PANews

“Not Your Keys, Not Your Coins.”

For everyone entering the crypto world, this is almost the first piece of advice they hear—and one of its most important tenets. But today, this slogan, once held up as a guiding principle by countless people, is facing a challenge.

Recently, Robbie Mitchnick, head of digital assets at BlackRock, revealed that large Bitcoin holders are converting self-custodied BTC into IBIT shares through in-kind transactions at an unprecedented pace. In his view, rising real-world security threats are making more and more holders realize that managing their own private keys may not be the safest option. However, this view has also sparked controversy in the Bitcoin community.

The Crypto World Is Losing Its Sense of Security

Imagine this scenario: you haven’t clicked on any phishing links, your wallet has never connected to a suspicious website, and your private keys and seed phrase have never been leaked. Yet one day, strangers suddenly knock at your door. They may be posing as delivery workers, food couriers, or even police officers. By the time you realize something is wrong, they have already taken control of your physical safety and are forcing you to hand over your seed phrase or open your wallet on the spot so they can transfer your assets.

This is the “wrench attack,” which has become increasingly common in the crypto world in recent years. It involves no complex code and requires no cracking of encryption algorithms; an ordinary “wrench” is enough to bypass layers of technical defenses. After all, when personal safety is threatened, even the most robust security measures can become useless. In recent years, such attacks have even escalated into kidnappings, serious injuries, and fatal acts of violence.

A report by blockchain security firm CertiK shows that 52 violent attacks targeting crypto holders were recorded worldwide in the first half of 2026, a year-on-year increase of 33.3%. The recorded funds at risk in these incidents totaled approximately $124.1 million, far exceeding the $10.5 million recorded a year earlier. France has become a major hotspot, with 33 incidents there alone, accounting for nearly two-thirds of the global total.

Attackers are no longer just searching for targets at random. They are beginning to combine on-chain transaction records, leaked customer databases, and social media information to identify high-net-worth crypto holders, determine the size of their assets, their routines, and information about their families, and then strike when the opportunity arises. People who once only needed to keep their private keys hidden must now also find ways to conceal their wealth and identity.

In addition to physical threats in the real world, the security risks of self-custody are also intensifying holders’ anxiety.

In recent months, hardware wallets have been hit by a series of supply chain security issues. Cold wallets, once considered safe havens for assets, no longer guarantee absolute security.

In the past, cold wallets were practically a must-have for long-term holders. With private keys stored offline and devices disconnected from the internet, assets seemed safe even if a computer was infected with malware. However, offline storage does not mean complete protection.

In August this year, a key-generation vulnerability that had existed in earlier versions of the Bitcoin-focused hardware wallet Coldcard led to the theft of hundreds of millions of dollars. In October, established hardware wallet manufacturer Ledger was caught up in a supply chain attack after devices sold through its Southeast Asian distributor CryptoBilis were found to contain unauthorized hardware implants. The associated losses are estimated to have reached as much as approximately $93 million. More recently, Trezor also confirmed that devices sold through CryptoBilis may have been similarly tampered with.

For the vast majority of ordinary users, these attacks are extremely difficult to detect and highly covert. It is nearly impossible to tell from a device’s appearance alone whether a hardware wallet has been fitted with malicious components. This hard-to-detect latent risk is further eroding users’ trust in hardware wallets.

Centralized exchanges (CEXs) are not absolutely safe havens either. In the past, many ordinary users preferred to keep their assets on leading exchanges because these platforms had professional security teams, comprehensive risk-control systems, and ample reserves. Compared with managing private keys themselves, exchanges seemed to offer more reliable security.

However, in recent years the impact of security incidents has spread from small and mid-sized platforms to leading exchanges, and a series of large-scale asset thefts has sounded the alarm for the market. In just the past few months, Bitget and Binance have both suffered major security incidents involving assets worth billions of dollars. Even leading platforms with ample reserves and the ability to compensate users cannot guarantee that their defenses will never be breached. In particular, as AI technology continues to advance, hacking techniques are becoming increasingly sophisticated, and the speed and stealth of attacks may improve further. Compensation may make up for financial losses, but once users’ trust is damaged, rebuilding it is no easy task.

From a wrench at the front door, to tampered-with hardware wallets, to leading exchanges coming under attack, the security defenses protecting crypto assets are facing unprecedented challenges.

Security concerns are driving whales toward ETFs, but self-custody advocates aren’t convinced

Some Bitcoin whales are handing their BTC over to Wall Street. For them, ETFs offer not only a new investment vehicle, but also peace of mind.

Last month, prominent analyst PlanB admitted that he moved his Bitcoin holdings into ETFs in 2025. The decision drew considerable criticism at the time, but following revelations about security concerns over Coldcard’s random number generation and unauthorized hardware implanted in Ledger devices, he said he did not regret choosing ETFs. He also said he was no longer a Bitcoin maximalist. He explained that he chose ETFs because they let him manage Bitcoin assets just like stocks and bonds, without having to deal with hardware wallets or the safekeeping of private keys. This way of holding Bitcoin gives him greater peace of mind.

In a recent interview, Mitchnick, head of digital assets at BlackRock, also said, “ETF demand is currently at a level we’ve never seen before, and it doesn’t change with Bitcoin’s price fluctuations. This type of asset-conversion demand has basically continued to grow.” Asked about the various reasons clients gave, he said plainly that the main reasons were security and peace of mind. For holders, outsourcing custody to an institutional-grade cold-storage setup is more appealing. Holding shares in an ETF managed by a large fund is generally considered less risky than keeping assets on a crypto exchange or in an always-online hot wallet.

Mitchnick disclosed that since regulators approved in-kind creations and redemptions for crypto assets last year, BlackRock has recorded approximately $3.6 billion in in-kind conversions of directly held Bitcoin into IBIT shares. Since BlackRock does not handle all transactions itself and the fund may not be aware of every conversion, the actual figure could be higher.

It is worth noting that this ETF product is also becoming accessible to more large investors. The minimum threshold for in-kind conversions into IBIT has now fallen from around $30 million initially to approximately $1 million to $2 million. Mitchnick hopes it can be lowered to a single ETF share, but the cost structure is unlikely to reach zero in the short term.

Many industry professionals have expressed similar views. Bitwise Chief Investment Officer Matt Hougan recently wrote that Binance being attacked does not mean the Bitcoin network itself has a security vulnerability; the real target was its hot-wallet system. Investors concerned about asset security can choose among several custody options: entrusting assets to a professional custodian, using a personal cold wallet, or holding Bitcoin through an ETF with multiple security safeguards. Crypto asset custody is now at its strongest point in history, and investors have not only more options to choose from, but also improved security.

Hougan emphasized that ETFs can provide long-term investors with an additional layer of security, with their underlying assets held by regulated custodians in cold wallets physically isolated from the internet. At Bitwise, for example, transfers from cold wallets require authorization from multiple people. Even if a single employee or device is compromised, a transfer cannot be triggered. In addition, assets can only be sent to a small number of pre-approved market-maker addresses authorized to create and redeem ETF shares. Even if a cold wallet is breached, it is difficult to transfer assets directly to a hacker’s address.

However, ETF security mechanisms also have certain limitations. He added that the underlying Bitcoin is transferred only once a day. Although ETF shares can be traded throughout the day, investors cannot immediately withdraw and transfer the corresponding Bitcoin. This makes ETFs more suitable for long-term investors than users who need to make instant transfers. In the future, this “layered storage” model will become the norm.

Du Jun, a partner at ABCDE Capital, recently disclosed that some family offices he had recommended allocate to BTC and ETH years ago have switched their BTC to IBIT after experiencing CEX thefts and cold-wallet supply chain security incidents. Some have even sold their crypto and switched to traditional assets such as physical gold.

However, ETF issuers’ use of security risks to promote institutional custody has also drawn criticism from self-custody advocates. In their view, Bitcoin was created precisely to free individuals from dependence on traditional financial institutions and allow them to truly control their own assets. Asset sovereignty and control are core values of cryptocurrency. Moving assets into the custody of traditional financial institutions is tantamount to embracing the old financial system anew, potentially reintroducing risks such as asset censorship and freezing, and running counter to the principles Bitcoin stands for.

Some, however, argue that whales turning to institutional custody does not mean they have lost faith in Bitcoin; rather, real-world security risks are changing their choices. This is especially true for investors whose identities are public and whose holdings are substantial: institutional-grade custody has become a practical way to hedge risk. Self-custody and institutional custody are not mutually exclusive. The former suits investors who value asset sovereignty and control, while the latter can meet large holders’ needs for security and convenient management.

In addition, the concentration risk of ETF custody has raised concerns in the market. Coinbase is the primary custodian for several major Bitcoin ETFs. According to its disclosures, it currently holds about 90% of the Bitcoin ETF custody market. This means that although investors hold ETF shares through different funds, a substantial portion of the underlying Bitcoin is actually safeguarded by the same institution.

OneKey founder Yishi once noted that the risk of BTC being highly concentrated in custody should not be overlooked, and said he suspected IBIT was on North Korea’s list of potential targets. Recent major crypto security incidents have been linked to North Korean hacking groups. Attacks often do not directly steal private keys, but instead infiltrate signers’ devices by posing as legitimate tools and hijack transaction approval interfaces. These risks also exist with cold storage and multisig processes. He pointed out that although Anchorage Digital has been appointed as an additional custodian, the latest quarterly filing shows there are currently no plans to transfer Bitcoin. Having Bitcoin so highly concentrated with a single custodian poses significant risks. If a major theft occurs and the fund cannot recover the Bitcoin or obtain sufficient compensation, IBIT shareholders will ultimately bear the remaining losses. Yishi recommends diversifying assets across independent custody arrangements, keeping private keys offline, independently verifying transaction details on a trusted device screen, and regularly reviewing security architecture.

Coinbase’s latest disclosures state that all assets in its custody vaults are held in cold storage and segregated on-chain. Its security measures include private-key sharding, signing without reconstructing the complete private key, limits on the rate at which funds can be transferred from cold wallets to hot wallets, monitoring for unusual activity, and an emergency stop mechanism that can take signing keys offline. Client assets are also held on a 1:1 basis and are not lent out or used for other purposes without client instructions.

Setting aside the debate between ETFs and self-custody, perhaps the question is not which method is the optimal solution for crypto asset custody, but how to weigh the risks and benefits of different custody methods based on one’s own asset scale and actual needs, and develop an asset management strategy that is better suited to oneself.