The immigration issue in EU countries has long concerned many experts, politicians, and ordinary citizens. Illegal migrants create a great many problems. Their unwillingness to assimilate into society creates divisions among the native population. Rising crime, pressure on the social system, political divisions, and growing radicalism. These are only some of the problems—the most obvious ones.

But in my humble opinion, there is a solution to this problem, and it consists of several laws that the EU and individual EU member states should adopt. The whole point of these laws is to organize and control migration.


1. Benefit periods and payments.

There are various benefits available to migrants—at least seven. This allows migrants to abuse the benefit system and “live off” taxpayers.

I propose combining all benefits into a single one with a limited duration.


This benefit would include:

1.1 Monthly payments.

The minimum subsistence level, or the family minimum subsistence level for families.

1.2 Housing provision.

Social housing with basic amenities.

1.3 Language and legal courses.

For the whole family, to speed up integration and provide knowledge of the country's basic laws.

1.4 Placement of children in school or kindergarten, and provision of basic school supplies (one-time).

This will help migrants' children assimilate more quickly and give adults time to look for work and obtain the necessary documents.

1.5 Basic health insurance.


   This benefit will be available for 6 months. After that, the migrant must pass an exam demonstrating knowledge of the language and basic laws, obtain a D work visa, find official employment, rent housing, and obtain health insurance. Children under 18 do not need to obtain a work visa or find employment. However, they must attend school or kindergarten.

   Failure to meet any of the conditions listed above will result in deportation and a 2-year entry ban.

  If one family member fails to meet one of the conditions, the family members who have met all the conditions have the right to choose whether to stay or leave with the family member who has failed to meet the condition(s).


2. Immigration tax.

  After meeting all the conditions and obtaining a D work visa, each migrant pays an additional tax called the “Immigration Tax.” This tax will apply until they obtain a residence permit or leave the country.

  Such a tax will help reduce the burden on the country's economy and lessen public dissatisfaction. The money will go toward benefits, building social housing provided to migrants under the benefit program, maintaining that housing, and partially funding the migration control service. In this way, migrants will essentially help other migrants move to the EU.


3. Grounds for deportation and crime control.


   Migrants increase crime in European countries, putting additional demands on security agencies and making cities less safe.

   Imprisoning them and feeding them at taxpayers' expense is the worst idea. In my opinion, deportation is a better response to breaking the law.

 

   Deportation conditions and penalties for breaking the law.

  Deporting everyone indiscriminately for breaking the law would be unwise, so there should be specific grounds for deportation and clear time periods.

  3.1 For minor offenses

For example, crossing the road when the light is red or smoking where it is prohibited, etc. Simple fines may be sufficient for offenses that cause no harm to a person or society. But if such violations are repeated and result in more than 20 fines in a year, the person should be deported for one year.

   3.2 For moderately serious offenses

For robbery, fraud, fighting that causes minor or moderate injuries, etc. Such offenses should result in deportation for 5 years and confiscation of property (savings, car(s)).

    3.3 For serious offenses

A prison sentence of up to 2 years under strict conditions, with a reduced budget per inmate, followed by permanent deportation.

The EU could also create a unified registry of such people, allowing other countries, if they wish, to see why a person was permanently deported.


4. Establishment of a migration control department.

This department will include:


4.1 A staff of control and inspection officers, with a system similar to the police.

This staff will also administer exams.

4.2 A judicial system that handles immigration cases only.

This will speed up deportation decisions.


   Of course, this is not all. Over time, problems will arise that require amendments to the laws and/or additions to them. These measures will also make EU countries less attractive to migrants, reducing the burden on new migration control agencies and the budget. At the same time, however, they will improve the quality of migrants.