IKOL Note #002 · What the NFL told the Supreme Court, and what several other leagues signed
Short answer: The NFL and Major League Baseball both say protecting game integrity is their top priority. On October 8, the NFL used that argument to urge the Supreme Court to take a case over whether states can apply their gambling laws to sports contracts on federally regulated prediction markets. Baseball, hockey and Major League Soccer have taken a different path: commercial partnerships with the platforms. Those are different strategies; a partnership announcement alone does not tell us where a league stands on the legal question.
【What the NFL filed】
[Documented] On October 8, 2026, the NFL filed an amicus brief supporting New Jersey's gaming regulators in Flaherty v. KalshiEX, LLC (No. 26-299). The brief describes a split: the Third Circuit held that Kalshi's sports event contracts, listed on a CFTC-designated exchange, are "swaps" under the CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction and preempt New Jersey's gambling laws; the Sixth and Ninth Circuits disagreed (p. 4). The NFL's counsel include former Attorney General William Barr.
[Documented] The brief states that on the first Sunday of the season, $1.8 billion of $3.3 billion in prediction-market trading volume related to the NFL (p. 1), and that "The NFL's highest priority is preserving the integrity of its games" (p. 2).
[Documented] What the brief argues about the federal route:
· The CFTC and exchanges have taken "a more laissez-faire approach" (p. 5).
· 18-year-olds can trade sports contracts on CFTC-regulated exchanges, while state-regulated sports betting generally requires bettors to be 21 (p. 5).
· Citing published figures, it compares the CFTC's 543 employees with roughly 400 at each of the Nevada and Pennsylvania gaming regulators (p. 6).
· Exchanges have not adopted the NFL's list of contract types it wants prohibited, such as contracts a single player could swing, like whether a kicker misses a field goal (p. 9).
[Documented] It asks the Court to grant review now, before another season, and argues that "swap" covers instruments that hedge an existing risk, not wagers that create a new one (pp. 7–8).
[Documented] As of October 18, the docket listed 11 amicus briefs, including the NFL's. Others include Ohio with 38 other states and the District of Columbia, whose brief calls the courts "hopelessly confused and divided"; the American Gaming Association; a coalition of 145 Indian tribes and tribal organizations; and former CFTC Chairman Gary Gensler.
【What other leagues signed】
[Documented] March 19, 2026: MLB named Polymarket its "Official Prediction Market Exchange" and signed a memorandum of understanding with the CFTC to share integrity information. MLB says it will work with Polymarket to restrict markets that pose integrity risks, citing individual pitches, manager decisions and umpire performance. Commissioner Manfred: "Protecting the integrity of the game on the field is our top priority." These are stated commitments, not evidence that the arrangements have reduced manipulation.
[Documented] January 26, 2026: MLS named Polymarket its "Official and Exclusive Prediction Market Partner," with what it calls safeguards including independent monitoring of trading activity.
[Reported] October 2025: the NHL signed multiyear deals with Kalshi and Polymarket covering league data, trademarks and broadcast signage.
[Reported] Asked about prediction markets, NBA Commissioner Adam Silver said, according to CNBC as reproduced by CDC Gaming (Oct. 9): "We want access to that data. We also want control of the market."
[Reported] As of October 18, our search found no announced prediction-market partnership for the NFL or the NBA.
【Two strategies, one concern】
[Analysis] These are different strategies for dealing with the same integrity concern. The NFL's brief argues that the jurisdiction question needs a clear answer and that states are better equipped to enforce protections. MLB, MLS and the NHL chose commercial partnerships; MLB and MLS also describe integrity arrangements that give them some role in which markets are offered. Partnership announcements alone do not establish where a league stands on the legal question before the Court, and the two approaches can coexist: leagues with partners still operate inside whatever legal framework the courts and regulators settle on.
[Documented] Separately, the CFTC is pursuing a rulemaking. On October 9 it proposed expressly clarifying that the definition of "swap" includes event contracts, including those based on sports, the same term at issue in the case. Chairman Michael Selig: "These products are commodity derivatives squarely within the CFTC's regulatory remit under the Commodity Exchange Act."
【What is not settled】
· Whether the Court will take the case. As of our October 18 docket check, no order granting or denying review was listed. Kalshi's response deadline had been extended to November 9. Granting review would not by itself mean the Court agrees with New Jersey.
· Whether league partnerships reduce manipulation. The sources reviewed here do not establish it.
· How the CFTC's proposal would interact with any ruling.
What protections should be mandatory for sports event contracts, whether states or the CFTC oversee them, and what can league partnerships add?
—————
Evidence: strong for what the filings and league announcements say (primary documents; "documented" means the document says it, not that its arguments are proven); moderate for the NHL deal and Silver's remarks (press reports); low for how any of this works in practice. Not legal or investment advice.
Sources
1. NFL amicus brief, Flaherty v. KalshiEX, No. 26-299 (Oct 8, 2026) — https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/26/26-299/428826/20261008053543625_NFL%20Amicus%20Brief.pdf
2. Supreme Court docket No. 26-299 (checked Oct 18, 2026) — https://www.supremecourt.gov/search.aspx?filename=/docket/docketfiles/html/public/26-299.html
3. Brief of Ohio, 38 other states and D.C. (Oct 7, 2026) — https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/26/26-299/428759/20261007134816267_Kalshi%20Cert%20Amicus.pdf
4. MLB press release (Mar 19, 2026) — https://www.mlb.com/press-release/press-release-mlb-names-polymarket-exclusive-prediction-market-exchange-partner-and-signs-agreement-with-cftc-to-establish-integrity-framework
5. MLS / Soccer United Marketing press release (Jan 26, 2026) — https://www.mlssoccer.com/news/soccer-united-marketing-and-polymarket-announce-multi-year-partnerships-with-major-league-soccer-and-leagues-cup
6. NHL deal, SVG News (Oct 22, 2025) — https://www.sportsvideo.org/2025/10/22/nhl-strikes-deal-with-prediction-market-companies-kalshi-and-polymarket/
7. Adam Silver on CNBC, via CDC Gaming (Oct 9, 2026) — https://cdcgaming.com/brief/nba-commissioner-says-league-wants-access-to-prediction-market-data-to-detect-manipulation/
8. CFTC Release No. 9310-26 (Oct 9, 2026) — https://www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/PressReleases/9310-26
IKOL · AI-assisted research, human-edited. We label what is documented, reported and analyzed — and publish our corrections.
