Taiwan stocks surged to a record high right at the opening today, while TSMC also hit a new all-time high. Bitcoin returned to around $86,000. The market generally believes that the likelihood of a Fed rate hike in October has fallen sharply. The reason: the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) reported on October 2 that nonfarm payrolls increased by just 29,000 in September, while the unemployment rate rose to 4.2%.
When job opportunities become scarcer, the Fed has one less reason to keep raising rates. If that narrative holds, then the question is: what exactly are the “odds” of a rate hike?
Four media outlets, four different probability figures:
Decrypt (10/2): Probability of a rate hike falls from 70% a week ago to 14%
Economic Daily News, citing CME (10/3): Probability of rates remaining unchanged climbs to nearly 84%
USTV News (10/4): 77.9% chance of rates remaining unchanged, 22.1% chance of a 25-basis-point hike
M平方 (10/3): Probability of a rate hike is 22.10%
---
So who calculates these percentages?
CME Group says these probabilities are “derived from 30-Day Federal Funds futures prices” and indicate “how likely traders think it is that the Fed will change interest rates.”
So the probability itself is derived from prices. Futures prices move every second, so the probability calculated from those prices moves along with them. The four media outlets simply recorded the number at different points in time; none of them reported it incorrectly.
That’s also why the probability of a rate hike can drop from 70% to around 20% in just one week. The Fed didn’t meet or issue any statements during that period. What changed was how the market reacted to new data, especially the employment report, which carried the most weight.
So it wasn’t the Fed that changed, but the investors putting money on the outcome.
---
Taiwan’s stock market climbed above 49,000 points less than ten minutes after opening today, and TSMC rose from NT$2,500. Bitcoin also climbed from around US$83,000 on October 1 to around US$86,000 this morning.
The same U.S. employment figures are moving both the ETF you invest in regularly and the coins in your account.
Honestly, I think the biggest problem with the probability of a rate hike isn’t that it’s inaccurate, but that people use it as “investment news.” You keep an eye on it and think you’re seeing what the Fed will do next.
But what you’re actually seeing is how much money the market is betting right now—and you’re part of that market, too. So using this to decide whether to add to your position today means using other people’s “now” prices to predict something in the “future” that hasn’t happened yet.
You might say that futures pricing reflects the collective judgment of the smartest money in the market and is more accurate than any commentary, so what’s wrong with following it?
This statement isn’t wrong in itself. It really is a real-time reflection of the market consensus at this very moment. It’s just not a forecast of the future. So if you’re planning to make decisions by watching the probability of a rate hike, I’d suggest doing two things first:
When you see a headline saying “XX% probability of a rate hike,” first check the date it was published. A day or two later, the number could be very different.
This percentage is calculated from bets placed by traders in the futures market. It doesn’t come from the Fed itself. We’ll have to wait for the outcome of the Fed meeting in the early hours of October 29, Taiwan time, to find out whether it will raise rates.
So what number are you waiting for before putting the money you’re holding on the sidelines to work?
Feel free to share your thoughts with me~
⚠️ The content above is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
