This morning, I saw a lot of people saying we’ve hit bottom. They had just two reasons: the Fear & Greed Index had crashed to 10, and Bitcoin had fallen below its 200-week moving average. Some headlines were already asking, “Is this really the bottom?”
Let’s lay out the numbers first.
Alternative.me’s index was at 10 yesterday and ticked up a little to 12 today. The label is still “Extreme Fear.” It was 32 last week and 53 a month ago. Dropping to around 10 only tells us that people in the market are badly shaken. It doesn’t automatically turn into buying pressure.
As for the 200-week moving average, the Strategy dashboard Saylor posted yesterday makes things pretty clear. At the time, the price was around $64,947, while the 200-week moving average was at $67,906—about 4.4% above the price. Historically, Bitcoin has spent only about 5.6% of the time below this line. Some people are using that 5.6% as proof that “once it gets here, it has to bounce.” That logic doesn’t hold. It only tells us how bad things look right now, and how rarely this has happened—not that the market owes anyone a reversal.
Bitcoin is around $64,977 on Binance spot right now, about the same as in yesterday’s screenshot, and still below the 200-week moving average. Today’s intraday low was $63,905 and the high was $65,696—almost flat. The weekend low of $62,006 hasn’t been retested yet.
And don’t rush to say the fund flows are improving, either. According to Farside, the preliminary total for Monday, November 16, was a net outflow of around $68.6 million. That looks much smaller than the outflows of $100–200 million or even $200–300 million we saw on some of the previous days. But the IBIT column is still blank, so this figure isn’t final. The previous week has already been checked: net outflows totaled around $1.065 billion over five trading days, and by last Friday it was the seventh consecutive day of outflows. Until IBIT’s numbers are in, it’s too early to say institutions have stopped selling. Saylor’s chart also showed two other figures: spot Bitcoin ETFs had net outflows of around $2.919 billion over the past 30 days, and around $1.671 billion over the past 7 days.
Bitcoin’s share of the total crypto market cap was at 66.9% in yesterday’s chart. That doesn’t mean Bitcoin is getting stronger; it means altcoins are falling harder, and money is retreating to places where it can still be put to work.
“Its index is at 10, and it’s fallen below the 200-week moving average, so we’ve hit bottom”—I don’t buy that argument. For the market to really hold up from here, we’d at least need to see ETF outflows actually stop and the price reclaim the 200-week moving average at around $67,900. Neither has happened yet.
U.S. October retail sales are due at 9:30 p.m. Beijing time tonight. Nvidia reports earnings at around 5:20 a.m. tomorrow, followed by its conference call at 6:00. If either of these sends the market lower again, a retest of the weekend low of $62,006 would make more sense than celebrating a bottom now, with the price hovering around $65,000.
#比特币 #FearAndGreedIndex
Let’s lay out the numbers first.
Alternative.me’s index was at 10 yesterday and ticked up a little to 12 today. The label is still “Extreme Fear.” It was 32 last week and 53 a month ago. Dropping to around 10 only tells us that people in the market are badly shaken. It doesn’t automatically turn into buying pressure.
As for the 200-week moving average, the Strategy dashboard Saylor posted yesterday makes things pretty clear. At the time, the price was around $64,947, while the 200-week moving average was at $67,906—about 4.4% above the price. Historically, Bitcoin has spent only about 5.6% of the time below this line. Some people are using that 5.6% as proof that “once it gets here, it has to bounce.” That logic doesn’t hold. It only tells us how bad things look right now, and how rarely this has happened—not that the market owes anyone a reversal.
Bitcoin is around $64,977 on Binance spot right now, about the same as in yesterday’s screenshot, and still below the 200-week moving average. Today’s intraday low was $63,905 and the high was $65,696—almost flat. The weekend low of $62,006 hasn’t been retested yet.
And don’t rush to say the fund flows are improving, either. According to Farside, the preliminary total for Monday, November 16, was a net outflow of around $68.6 million. That looks much smaller than the outflows of $100–200 million or even $200–300 million we saw on some of the previous days. But the IBIT column is still blank, so this figure isn’t final. The previous week has already been checked: net outflows totaled around $1.065 billion over five trading days, and by last Friday it was the seventh consecutive day of outflows. Until IBIT’s numbers are in, it’s too early to say institutions have stopped selling. Saylor’s chart also showed two other figures: spot Bitcoin ETFs had net outflows of around $2.919 billion over the past 30 days, and around $1.671 billion over the past 7 days.
Bitcoin’s share of the total crypto market cap was at 66.9% in yesterday’s chart. That doesn’t mean Bitcoin is getting stronger; it means altcoins are falling harder, and money is retreating to places where it can still be put to work.
“Its index is at 10, and it’s fallen below the 200-week moving average, so we’ve hit bottom”—I don’t buy that argument. For the market to really hold up from here, we’d at least need to see ETF outflows actually stop and the price reclaim the 200-week moving average at around $67,900. Neither has happened yet.
U.S. October retail sales are due at 9:30 p.m. Beijing time tonight. Nvidia reports earnings at around 5:20 a.m. tomorrow, followed by its conference call at 6:00. If either of these sends the market lower again, a retest of the weekend low of $62,006 would make more sense than celebrating a bottom now, with the price hovering around $65,000.
#比特币 #FearAndGreedIndex
