At 00:35 UTC on November 19, Bitcoin returned to around 63,016 USDT, but was still down 2.77% over the past 24 hours. Meanwhile, U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs have seen net outflows for two days in a row. Outflows on the 18th totaled about $306.5 million, $66.6 million more than on the 17th. Look further down the table, though, and there’s something interesting: the largest fund actually saw smaller outflows on the second day.
IBIT’s outflows were smaller, so why was the total higher?
On the 17th, BlackRock’s IBIT saw net outflows of $209.5 million. On the 18th, its outflows narrowed to $148.7 million, while Fidelity’s FBTC and Bitwise’s BITB saw outflows of $69.3 million and $36.6 million, respectively. Excluding IBIT, the other funds’ combined net outflows widened from about $30.4 million to about $158 million. Focusing on just one BlackRock fund over these two days makes it easy to miss the changes in other providers’ products.
This table can also explain why I didn’t take the move into positive territory on the 16th too seriously. That day IBIT had $76.5 million of inflows, but after adding up all products there was only $7.9 million in net inflows. A single subscription from a few large funds can flip the day from negative to positive. Next time I see the total turn positive, I’ll also check how many products turned around together; that can help me judge whether buying has become broader.
Back near 63,000, see how much volume is on the order book
If you want to see how BTC spot trades are executed, you can open the BTC/USDT order book in BiyaPay. For example, if the screen shows 63,000, but the best ask is posted higher and there is only a small amount of volume, a larger buy order will be filled at increasingly expensive quotes behind it. At that point I’d first look at the spread between bids and asks, and how much is posted at the nearby levels. If you want to buy within a certain price, a limit order can hold that ceiling, while execution has to wait for the other side.
BiyaPay allows deposits in USDT, which can be converted into dollars and directly injected into a stock trading account, eliminating steps such as opening an offshore bank account. In addition, BiyaPay’s digital currency-to-fiat trading feature also provides investors with a brand-new, more intuitive interface and trading experience, making it easy to invest in Bitcoin.
I treat ETF net flows as a single trading-day reading. One investor sells ETF shares in a U.S. stock account, while another investor can take them on directly. Net outflow statistics need to look at the actual creation and redemption of shares at the fund level; that is a different matter from how much money traded on the secondary market each day. Take IBIT’s prospectus as an example: the product allows authorized participants to handle basket creations and redemptions in cash or Bitcoin. Daily net outflows can show which side redemptions and creations are leaning toward, but from this one column alone, you can’t infer that an equivalent amount of Bitcoin was directly pushed into the spot market at some point.
Fund net asset value is just as easy to misread. A simple example: if a fund’s Bitcoin holdings haven’t changed but the coin price falls 3%, then the mere revaluation of the position is enough to push down the dollar amount on the fund’s books. To confirm whether the coins the fund holds have decreased, I’d look at the disclosed BTC quantity and shares. Only by comparing those two items with net flows can you tell whether the shrinkage came from price or from creations and redemptions.
Combined net outflows on the 17th and 18th were about $546 million. Next I’ll see whether the funds with net redemptions have shrunk, while also watching whether trades keep following after spot prices recover. BTC trades around the clock; the Asian session can push prices back to 63,000, and during the U.S. session they may still get sold down. Sometimes a single trade touches 63,000, while other times there are several rounds of sell orders and people willing to absorb them nearby; the signals are quite different.