In a 46-page ruling, Manhattan federal judge Jessica Clarke let the two brothers walk free. MIT graduates Anton and James Peraire-Bueno allegedly made off with about $25 million from Ethereum sandwich bots in 12 seconds on April 12, 2023. Prosecutors charged them with wire fraud and money laundering, but the judge said the evidence wasn’t enough. Case closed.

The scheme wasn’t complicated; what’s outrageous is the judge’s reasoning. First, they baited sandwich bots with fake trades, then exploited a flaw in MEV-Boost relays to get block contents in advance and arrange the transaction order themselves. The judge’s exact words: Ethereum is a “highly adversarial, trustless environment without terms of service.” Prosecutors couldn’t prove material deception; being obnoxious doesn’t make it a crime.

The jury deadlocked in 2025, resulting in a mistrial, and there won’t be a retrial. So here’s the question: when there are no rules on-chain, is exploiting a loophole for profit skill—or fraud?