Ethereum’s biggest problem is both technical and philosophical.
Recently, Vitalik’s remarks that ETH should be viewed more as a Store of Value than as a Fee Burning Asset have raised several bigger questions for me.
1. ETH’s value-capture problem can’t be solved by redefining it.
Over the past few years, Vitalik and the Ethereum Foundation have strongly advocated for a Rollup-centric Roadmap.
The industry has poured enormous resources into building L2s.
And the result?
There are more and more L2s, the ecosystem is becoming increasingly fragmented, liquidity is scattered, and users have to deal with different networks, bridges, and assets.
More importantly, the growth in L2 economic activity has not translated into ETH capturing value in proportion.
Today, Vitalik has begun to reassess the Rollup-centric Roadmap, acknowledging that the original positioning of L2s is no longer fit for purpose.
This in fact reveals a strategic problem:
Why is a strategy once considered central to Ethereum’s long-term development being revisited after massive investment? And when an ecosystem’s core strategy keeps changing, who bears the cost of past strategic choices?
2. Vitalik now wants ETH to become a Store of Value—but where will that value come from?
On November 8, Vitalik proposed that ETH should be viewed more as a store of value, rather than relying on fee burning to support its value.
He even suggested there was no need to be disappointed if fee burning remained below 10% of the breakeven level over the long term.
I want to ask a very direct question:
If ETH doesn’t rely on fee burning or deflation, where exactly will its long-term value come from?
Network usage?
But doesn’t that leave the network’s real demand and user growth unresolved?
Decentralization?
Then how does decentralization itself translate into economic value for ETH holders?
Ecosystem consensus?
Then why must ETH be the vehicle for that value?
We can’t turn around and expect the market to accept that ETH should be a store of value simply because it already has a huge market capitalization.
Being a store of value is more an aspiration than an identity a founder can assign to an asset. It must stand the test of the market over time.
3. I also disagree with the idea that BTC is a store of value.
Gold became a store of value through the combined effects of its physical properties, real-world demand, and cross-civilizational consensus over thousands of years.
BTC’s scarcity, decentralization, and global liquidity certainly have value.
But mathematical scarcity is not entirely the same as a store of value in the economic sense.
I’m more inclined to view BTC as an alternative risk asset with high liquidity, strong market consensus, and high volatility.
Whether it can truly become a store of value across multiple economic cycles will take more time to prove.
What’s even more interesting is this:
If ETH is also going down the store-of-value path, what exactly is its core difference from BTC?
If ETH’s value no longer comes primarily from network usage and economic activity, what justifies an independent monetary premium for it?
This is a question Ethereum must answer today.
4. Ethereum’s biggest predicament is that its technology has stopped advancing.
We recognize Ethereum’s irreplaceable historical contributions in areas such as smart contracts, DeFi, stablecoins, and the developer ecosystem.
But historical contributions are not the same as future competitiveness.
Over the past few years, we’ve seen too much effort poured into Rollups, modularity, data availability, and various foundational architectures and technical roadmaps.
This work is, of course, important.
But has the Ethereum ecosystem produced enough new products in recent years that users actively want to use?
Has it also created new business models and new market demand?
If the answer is unsatisfactory, then we can say that Ethereum’s development roadmap has failed.
Ethereum’s problem today is not a lack of researchers. It’s a lack of product innovation capable of reinvigorating the industry, and a lack of progress in expanding Ethereum’s own capacity.
5. Vitalik should spend less time redefining things and more time on genuine product innovation and the technology itself.
I have great respect for Vitalik’s historical contributions to the blockchain industry.
But I believe Ethereum cannot define its future forever through discussions of Vitalik’s technical ideas and philosophy.
The market won’t keep rewarding a founder’s idealism.
Nor will users automatically choose a network just because it excels at one particular feature.
I believe the Ethereum Foundation should seriously study and learn from the Solana Foundation’s ecosystem strategy.
The first priority is solving the TPS problem, followed by learning from its focus on developer experience, consumer applications, product innovation, user growth, and the business ecosystem.
Public blockchain foundations should care not only about how the protocol evolves, but also about how the ecosystem creates new demand.
6. Networks without users, applications, or sustained innovation will eventually be abandoned by the market.
The blockchain industry is no longer in its early days, when simply telling a story about new technology was enough to attract capital and developers.
Today, users have a choice.
Developers have a choice.
Capital has a choice, too.
Ethereum cannot rely forever on its historical status, first-mover advantage, and the influence of its founder’s ideas to remain competitive.
If a network becomes increasingly complex and difficult to use, the user experience shows no meaningful improvement, innovation can’t keep pace with competitors, and economic value fails to flow effectively back to the underlying asset, then it must accept being repriced by the market.
Stop trying to solve ETH’s value-creation problem by redefining its value narrative.
Don’t mistake historical contributions for a future moat.
Don’t let the entire industry spend years building infrastructure, only to find out in the end that it was heading in the wrong direction.
ETH doesn’t need yet another new narrative.
ETH needs next-generation technology, products, applications, and business models that can make a real impact.
A public blockchain’s success isn’t measured by how grand its vision is, but by how many people are still willing to use it once its founder’s narrative is gone.
How long has it been since you last used the Ethereum network?
