"A trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use." That's a US federal judge describing #Ethereum, and it just ended the government's first criminal MEV case.

What happened (CoinDesk, Nov 18): Judge Jessica Clarke acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno on Nov 16 of wire fraud and money laundering conspiracy. Prosecutors said the brothers took about $25M from trading bots in 12 seconds in April 2023.

Why it failed:
• Wire fraud needs a material lie. The judge wrote that no trader who puts a transaction in the public mempool would agree to be sandwiched, so a pending trade isn't a promise.
• The falsified signature fields were never checked by the relay, so they changed nothing for the recipient.
• She cited a 2022 Second Circuit ruling: conduct that is "improper, objectionable, or even despicable" isn't automatically a crime.

My read: the ruling doesn't say the trade was fine, only that this statute didn't fit. Builders and relays still own the fix, since code is now the only real rulebook on $ETH . If courts won't treat this as fraud, who should close the gap: validators, builders or app developers?

Disclosure: Write to Earn may pay me a commission on cashtag trades.