Hyperliquid Policy Center urges CFTC to keep gambling exclusion intact, clarify event-contract rules Hyperliquid Policy Center (HPC) has filed two letters with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission backing a regulatory split that treats exchange-traded event contracts differently from casino-style wagers. Dated Nov. 16 and signed by CEO Jake Chervinsky and senior counsel Brad Bourque, the submissions ask the CFTC to preserve the text of its newly issued gambling exclusion and to explicitly link that exclusion to a companion proposal that would classify event contracts as swaps. Public comments on both actions are due Nov. 18. Why this matters The filings come amid a broader federal-state clash over whether state gambling laws can reach products that operate like tradable derivatives. HPC — an independent research and advocacy group — argues a national framework is needed to distinguish market-traded event contracts from bets offered by state- or tribal-licensed gambling operators. That distinction is central to how U.S. regulators and courts will treat crypto-based prediction markets and other outcome-based instruments. The rules in question - The gambling exclusion, published Oct. 19 and effective immediately as an interim final rule, removes qualifying sportsbook wagers and casino games from the CFTC’s definition of a “swap” (one of the core derivatives categories the agency oversees). HPC says it supports that interim final rule “without qualification” and urges the commission to leave the rule text unchanged. - A companion proposal would expressly bring event contracts — those tied to sports, politics, culture, weather and similar outcomes — within the swap definition. That proposal remains open for comment and has not been finalized. HPC’s arguments and drafting requests HPC emphasizes functional differences between customer wagers against a house and exchange-traded contracts with market liquidity and clearing. Key distinctions the group highlights: - Casino-style bets sit between a customer and the house until settlement; exchange-traded contracts can be sold or closed before settlement. - Registered exchanges generate transaction fees regardless of event outcomes and transact through registered clearinghouses; they don’t assume counterparty risk the way bucket-shop-style operators historically did. HPC also argues similar economic outcomes don’t require identical legal treatment, pointing to insurance policies and credit default swaps as examples of different regulatory regimes for functionally comparable protections. Specific drafting recommendations in the letters: - Add a cross-reference in the proposed event-contract rule that explicitly points back to the gambling exclusion, so the two texts work together. - Clarify that “applicable state or tribal law” means the law of the jurisdiction that licenses a gambling operator — not the most restrictive law elsewhere. - Confirm that a state characterizing an exchange-traded contract as a “wager” should not automatically trigger the gambling exclusion, and extend this protection to privately negotiated event-based swaps. - Define “event contracts” in statutory terms as instruments that pay on the occurrence or non-occurrence of a specified contingency, distinguishing them from derivatives tied to commodity-price movements. Historical and legal context HPC traces the roots of today’s dispute to 19th-century state laws that treated futures trading as gambling. Over time, federal legislation carved out designated exchanges from “bucket shops” — operators that assumed customer risk — a distinction HPC says has been preserved through modern derivatives law. The filings arrive while the CFTC is actively defending its jurisdiction in court. On Nov. 13 the agency said it sued Louisiana after the state obtained an order targeting more than 30 firms involved in federally regulated derivatives trading; the suit was described as the CFTC’s 12th state lawsuit defending exclusive federal jurisdiction. The agency also highlighted an earlier lawsuit against Arkansas — its 11th — which involves state allegations against Kalshi for illegal gambling and deceptive practices; the CFTC contends the transactions fall under its authority. Hyperliquid products and U.S. market initiatives HPC’s advocacy intersects with product initiatives from Hyperliquid itself. Its HIP-4 framework describes fully collateralized outcome contracts that operate without leverage or liquidations; an initial market is a recurring Bitcoin binary that settles daily at 06:00 UTC via paired Yes and No tokens whose order books share liquidity. An August report documented deployment of the OUT token through HIP-4, indicating event-based trading on the network predates the recent policy letters. Separately, a U.S.-access plan involves Payward’s proposed regulated markets using Hyperliquid’s HIP-3 infrastructure: an Oct. 26 outline described Bitnomial administering perpetual futures markets and NinjaTrader Clearing holding customer accounts, subject to regulatory approval. Bottom line HPC’s submissions press the CFTC to maintain a clear statutory and regulatory boundary between casino-style gambling and exchange-traded event contracts — a separation that will steer how crypto prediction markets and outcome-based products are regulated and litigated in the U.S. The commission’s final drafting choices, and how courts respond to state enforcement actions, will shape whether those markets can operate under federal derivatives rules or fall within state gambling regimes. Read more AI-generated news on: https://app.chaingpt.org/news